Category Archives: Judgements

Acknowledgement of Notice served u/s 143(2) not available, Assessment is Void

By | November 25, 2016

Held The AO had failed to produce any evidence regarding the issuance of notice or service of said notice. In our opinion, notice of hearing should not only the issue properly but it has to be served upon the assessee and the prove of service has to be placed on record. In the case under… Read More »

Service Tax on Air Conditioned Restaurants is unconstitutional

By | November 24, 2016

HIGH COURT OF KERALA Kerala Classified Hotels & Resorts Association v. Union of India A.M. SHAFFIQUE, J. W.P. (C) NO. 19277 OF 2013 OCTOBER  31, 2016 V. Krishna Kumar, G. Subodhan, Surendradas B., N. Vijayan Pillai, K.V. Rajappan Pillai and K.K. Radhakrishnanfor the Petitioner. N. Nagaresh, Ramavarma Reghunathan Thamburan, John Varghese and M.M. Jasmin for… Read More »

Sec .23(1) applies if buildings let out by owner to his own company

By | November 24, 2016

Facts of the case The property is owned by the co-owners themselves, who are also the Directors of the lessee company which has established the Hospital. As per the lease agreement between the co-owners and the lessee company, the mutually agreed rent is Rs.1 per sq.ft. However, a portion of the very same building is… Read More »

Expenditure on advertisement on television is Revenue Expenditure

By | November 22, 2016

Facts of the case The Assessee incurred expenditure on advertisement on television aggregating to Rs.29.99 crores. This expenditure related to advertisements published on television relating not only to individual products manufactured by it but also towards corporate advertisement to the extent of Rs.5.47 crores. The Assessing Officer disallowed the expenditure claimed towards corporate advertisement amounting… Read More »

SAP software Implementation fees is revenue expenditure : HC

By | November 22, 2016

Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Tribunal was right in treating the professional fees paid to its collaborator KSB AG of Germany for implementing the SAP programme as an allowable expenditure when the use of this software enhances the efficiency of the organization which is enduring… Read More »

Switching over from cash to mercantile system is not permissible in middle of FY : HC

By | November 22, 2016

Question  whether the Income Tax Officer was justified in refusing to permit the assessees switching over from the cash to the mercantile system during the midst of the financial year ? Held A switch over in the midst of an accounting year, especially in such cases, could lead to skewed results. An assessee could then… Read More »

No penalty on possession of high denomination notes if period to encash expired

By | November 22, 2016

Facts of the case The Income-tax Officer for the assessment year, namely, 1978-79 had levied a penalty of Rs. 95,000 after completion of the assessment proceedings for the relevant assessment year by invoking the provisions under section 271(1)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (‘Act’ for short), on the ground, that though the assessee is the… Read More »

Taxation of high denomination notes encashed as undisclosed Income

By | November 19, 2016

Facts of the case   On January 22, 1946, Banerjee encashed high denomination notes of the value of Rs. 51,000. In his application under the Ordinance which demonetized high denomination notes, Banerjee gave the reason for the possession of the notes as follows : “I am engaged in business as colliery proprietor, contractor, under Messrs.… Read More »

High denomination notes represent concealed income ? Burden of Proof

By | November 19, 2016

“Whether there was any material for the finding given by the Tribunal that out of 21 high denomination notes, which were exchanged by the assessee, 13 represented income of the assessee from some undisclosed source.” Held The burden is upon the department to prove that high denomination notes represent the concealed income of an assessee… Read More »

Deposit of high denomination notes can’t be unexplained when Cash Balance is Available

By | November 19, 2016

Facts of the case On 19-1-1978, the assessee tendered and deposited with the State Bank of India, Calcutta, 81 high denomination notes of Rs. 1,000 each. The assessee also furnished a declaration as required at the time of tender of high denomination notes. Columns 15 and 16 of the aforesaid declaration furnished are as under… Read More »