E-way bill not made, Seized vehicle could be released without security if there was no possibility of evasion of tax: HC

By | June 21, 2018
(Last Updated On: June 21, 2018)


Puneet Automobiles Ltd.


State of U.P.


WRIT TAX NO. 99 OF 2018

JANUARY  31, 2018

Shubham Agrawal and Rituraj Singh for the Petitioner. Gyan Prakash, C.S.C. for the Respondent.


1. Heard Sri Shubham Agrawal, learned counsel for the petitioner and Sri C.B. Tripathi special counsel has appeared for the State of U.P. and Sri Anant Kumar Tiwari learned counsel for Union of India.

2. The new loader/tipper with temporary registration no.- JH05AL3889 coming from Jamshedpur (Tata Motors Limited) was detained and seized under Section 129(1) of U.P. GST on 02-01-2018 thereafter an order of penalty has been passed on 07-01-2018 under Section 129(3) of the U.P. GST Act. These two order have been impugned by means of this writ petition. The submission of learned counsel for the petitioner is that the seizure has been done on account of non furnishing of the E-Way Bill immediately at the time of detention.

3. The further submission is that the requirement of E-Way Bill has been made applicable under the Central GST with effect from 1st February, 2018 and was not in place on the date of seizure though the State of U.P. alone has made a provision for the E-Way Bill earlier but that was not applicable to the State of Jharkhand from where the said loader/tipper had started journey.

4. In view of the facts and circumstances, notwithstanding the remedy of appeal against the order of the seizure, the loader/tipper were duly supported by other documents including temporary registration number ensuring no possibility of evasion of tax, as provided in other matters of the similar nature, we direct the respondent to release the loader/tipper without demanding any security from the petitioner forthwith leaving the order of penalty to be challenged by the petitioner if necessary by means of an appeal under Section 107 of the U.P. GST if so advised.

5. Sri C.B. Tripathi, may file reply to this writ petition within a period of three weeks. Two weeks thereafter is allowed to the petitioner for filing rejoinder affidavit.

6. List for admission/final disposal on the expiry of the above period.

Other GST Judgments

Free Study Material on Eway Bill System of India

[ Join online GST Course by CA Satbir Singh ]

Eway bill login Official website in India

Bill to Ship to under GST and Eway Bill : Analysis

Whether Eway bill required for Exports of Goods

Multi Vehicle Option for e-Way bill

[Video] Eway Bill New Updates on EWay bill Portal : GST News 326

Bill To Ship To issues of Eway Bill Clarified by Govt

Two different dates for Tax Invoice and Eway bill Allowed ?

JSON Upload Error Codes on Eway Bill Portal

E way Bill Preparation tool , e way Bill Json Format : Download

JSON file on E-Way Bill Portal not uploading : solution

Register on E Way Bill Portal even if already registered on GST Portal

Eway Bill for SEZ within state : Important Notice

Govt mistake in making GST Law for detention and seziure and release of goods and conveyances in transit.

e-Way Bill Roll out for intra-State in Maharashtra, Manipur & UT’s (without legislature) from 25.05.2018

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.