- 1 GST Sugar Cess
- 1.1 History of Sugar Cess
- 1.2 Why GST Sugar Cess will be imposed
- 1.3 Can the GST Sugar Cess be imposed ?
- 1.4 How much GST Sugar Cess Govt Planned to Impose
- 1.5 How the GST Sugar Cess will be Imposed
- 1.6 Who are the members of Group to recommend GST Sugar Cess
- 1.7 Within How many Days group will submit report to recommend GST Sugar Cess
- 1.8 Whether GST Sugar Cess will be part of Compensation Cess under GST
- 1.9 How GST Sugar Cess will be Implemented
- 1.10 Why Decision to defer GST Sugar Cess may have been Taken
- 1.11 Likely Impact of GST Sugar Cess
- 1.12 Open Issues in GST Sugar Cess
- 1.13 Related New Books on GST
- 1.14 Related Topics on GST
GST Sugar Cess
Govt is considering imposition of GST Sugar Cess . Refer 27th GST Council Meeting Decisions on 04.05.2018.
History of Sugar Cess
India last had a Sugar cess under The Sugar Cess Act 1982, the Sugar Development Fund Act 1982, but was abolished in 2017.
Why GST Sugar Cess will be imposed
The GST Council in its 27th GST Council Meeting discussed the issue of imposition of sugar cess and reduction in GST rate on ethanol in great detail because of the record production of sugar in the current sugar season, and consequent depressed sugar prices and build-up of sugarcane arrears.
Thus the GST Council discussed the proposal to impose a cess on sugar over and above the five per cent GST considering the sugarcane farmers were in distress with the cost of producing sugar being significantly higher than its market price.
FM Arun Jaitley said after the meeting that cane growers were in deep distress as the cost of sugar production is over Rs 35 per kg, while the market price of sugar is around Rs 26-28 a kg. The cess on sugar was proposed to raise money to compensate farmers for a loss due to surplus production.
Jaitley said that the discussions have thrown up several new aspects. “How are such contingencies to be addressed in the GST regime, are they to be addressed by imposition of cess or are they to be addressed by temporarily increasing the tax or by some alternative method of revenue raising?”
The ministerial panel would make a recommendation to the council on the avenues to raise revenue to meet contingencies of this kind where the cost of commodity is much higher than its selling price.
Jaitley said the Council had decided to set up a group of five ministers within two days to make a recommendation on ways to meet such contingencies where the cost of a commodity is higher than its selling price.
Can the GST Sugar Cess be imposed ?
whether the Council at all has the power to impose cess. ? Refer Opinion From Law And Food Ministries invited by Govt on GST Sugar Cess
How much GST Sugar Cess Govt Planned to Impose
Proposal before GST Council was to levy Rs 3-a-kg sugar cess,
How the GST Sugar Cess will be Imposed
The GST council in its 27th GST Council Meeting has recommended for setting up of a Group of Ministers from State Governments to look into the proposal and make recommendations, within two weeks from 04.05.2018 , keeping in mind the views expressed in GST Council in this regard.
Who are the members of Group to recommend GST Sugar Cess
Details of Members of this Group of Ministers
- Shri Himanta Biswa Sarma, Finance Minister of Assam [ convenor ]
- Shri Rajesh Agrawal, Finance Minister, Uttar Pradesh;
- Shri Sudhir Mungatiwar, Finance Minister, Maharashtra;
- Shri D. Jayakumar, Minister for Fisheries and Personnel & Administrative Reforms, Tamil Nadu
- Dr. T.M. Thomas Isaac, Finance Minister, Kerala.
Within How many Days group will submit report to recommend GST Sugar Cess
GoMs shall submit their reports within a period of 15 days from 04.05.2018
Whether GST Sugar Cess will be part of Compensation Cess under GST
The proposed cess will be outside the purview of the compensation cess under the GST and will require a separate law.
How GST Sugar Cess will be Implemented
“The cess will be imposed through an ordinance once the Council approves it,” said a source.
Why Decision to defer GST Sugar Cess may have been Taken
Protest by some states, including Kerala, West Bengal and Andhra Pradesh, prompted the GST Council to order a review of the plan to levy a cess on sugar to “help” sugarcane growers as they complained that the move would only benefit Uttar Pradesh, Maharashtra and poll-bound Karnataka, while discarding the basic principle of the new regime that focused on removing all additional levies. The cess would have helped government raise Rs 6,700 crore.
During discussions on the cess, which stretched for over two hours in GST Council meeting, these states, with support from Tamil Nadu, Delhi and Pondicherry, argued that imposition of a cess on sugar will also make other states such as Kerala, West Bengal and Punjab demand a similar benefit for rubber, jute and foodgrains.
“There will be no end and will defeat the very purpose of GST,” said a source, adding that some of the finance ministry officials were also sympathetic to this argument.
While introducing GST, the Centre and the states decided to abolish all cesses and surcharges other than compensation cess (covering luxury and sin goods) for a period of five years.
The states opposing the cess suggested that UP and Maharashtra, which are grappling with the problem, should provide budgetary support as the move is only going to benefit sugar mills in their jurisdictions, although the cess will be paid by consumers across the country to help farmers.
The non-sugar producing states argued they would not get a portion of the cess collected from taxpayers of their states.
“I shall agree to a cess only if similar treatment is offered to rubber,” said the Kerala finance minister in a tweet after the meeting
Likely Impact of GST Sugar Cess
Imposition of Sugar cess could mean that not only the price of sugar, but the prices of products like sweets, confectioneries, chocolates etc. which use sugar as a key ingredient, are also likely to go up, thereby negatively impacting the end consumer.
Open Issues in GST Sugar Cess
- If the cess is imposed, it is not clear on how it would be applied – would it be a cess of GST or on the cost of the product.
- Whether you will get Input Tax Credit of GST Sugar cess is also not clear. If it is not creditable then it would mean the burden on the sector would be passed on to the consumers. It will also increase the compliance burden for the taxpayer.
Related New Books on GST
Related Topics on GST
Refer Govt Website on GST
sugar cess latest news , sugar cess rate , cess on sugar in gst , sugar cess meaning , sugar cess in india ,sugar cess under gst