<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	>

<channel>
	<title>AGRA BENCH Archives - Tax Heal</title>
	<atom:link href="https://www.taxheal.com/tag/agra-bench/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
	<link>https://www.taxheal.com/tag/agra-bench</link>
	<description>Complete Guide for Income Tax and GST in India</description>
	<lastBuildDate>Fri, 13 Nov 2026 08:24:12 +0000</lastBuildDate>
	<language>en-US</language>
	<sy:updatePeriod>
	hourly	</sy:updatePeriod>
	<sy:updateFrequency>
	1	</sy:updateFrequency>
	<generator>https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4</generator>
	<item>
		<title>Revenue Second Appeal Confined Solely to Fine Without Challenging Penalty Is Not Maintainable Before Tribunal</title>
		<link>https://www.taxheal.com/and-vivek-kumar-technical-member-9.html</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashwani Kumar]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Fri, 13 Nov 2026 08:24:12 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[GST]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[AGRA BENCH]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[GOODS AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.taxheal.com/?p=143688</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Revenue Second Appeal Confined Solely to Fine Without Challenging Penalty Is Not Maintainable Before Tribunal Issue Whether a second appeal filed by the Revenue before the Appellate Tribunal under Section 112 read with Section 107 of the CGST/UPGST Act is maintainable when it challenges only the deletion of the fine while leaving the deletion of… <span class="read-more"><a href="https://www.taxheal.com/and-vivek-kumar-technical-member-9.html">Read More &#187;</a></span></p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="model-response-message-contentr_b40384d4a630928e" class="markdown markdown-main-panel md-content enable-luminous-fast-follows enable-updated-hr-color tutor-markdown-rendering" dir="ltr" aria-busy="false" aria-live="polite">
<div dir="ltr"><strong>Revenue Second Appeal Confined Solely to Fine Without Challenging Penalty Is Not Maintainable Before Tribunal</strong></div>
<h3 dir="ltr" data-path-to-node="2">Issue</h3>
<div dir="ltr">Whether a second appeal filed by the Revenue before the Appellate Tribunal under Section 112 read with Section 107 of the CGST/UPGST Act is maintainable when it challenges only the deletion of the fine while leaving the deletion of the accompanying penalty unchallenged.</div>
<h3 dir="ltr" data-path-to-node="5">Facts</h3>
<ul dir="ltr" data-path-to-node="6">
<li>
<div dir="ltr">The respondent-firm underwent a search operation conducted under Section 67 of the CGST/UPGST Act.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr">Following the search, the Proper Officer invoked Section 130(2) read with Section 122 to impose a penalty of approximately Rs. 0.95 lakh and a fine of approximately Rs. 0.50 lakh.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr">On first appeal, the Appellate Authority held that while proceedings under Section 73 or 74 could be initiated in a search case, the levy and collection of penalty and fine under Sections 130(2) and 122 were unsustainable.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr">Aggrieved by this order, the Revenue filed a second appeal before the Appellate Tribunal, restricting its challenge solely to the fine component without assailing the findings on penalty.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<h3 dir="ltr" data-path-to-node="8">Decision</h3>
<ul dir="ltr" data-path-to-node="9">
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="9,0,0" data-index-in-node="0">Omission to Challenge Penalty:</b> The Tribunal noted that the department had challenged the first appellate findings exclusively regarding the fine and had left the findings setting aside the penalty completely unassailed.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="9,1,0" data-index-in-node="0">Appeal Non-Maintainable:</b> Because the substantive findings regarding the penalty were not contested, a piecemeal second appeal confined solely to the fine component could not be entertained in law.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="9,2,0" data-index-in-node="0">Summary Dismissal:</b> Consequently, the second appeal filed by the Revenue was held to be not maintainable and was dismissed summarily in favor of the assessee.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<h3 dir="ltr" data-path-to-node="11">KeyTakeways</h3>
<ul dir="ltr" data-path-to-node="12">
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="12,0,0" data-index-in-node="0">No Selective Challenge of Interlinked Levies:</b> Where an appellate authority sets aside both penalty and confiscation fine on foundational grounds, the Revenue cannot selectively appeal only the fine while allowing the penalty deletion to attain finality.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="12,1,0" data-index-in-node="0">Appropriate Procedure in Search Cases:</b> Discrepancies uncovered during a search under Section 67 require adjudication through regular demand provisions (Sections 73/74) rather than summary confiscation and penalty under Sections 130(2) and 122.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="12,2,0" data-index-in-node="0">Maintainability Threshold:</b> Departmental appeals framed in a fragmented manner that fail to assail core adverse findings are liable to summary dismissal at the threshold.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<div>
<div id="111070000000000133" style="text-align: center;">GOODS AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL , <span class="researchdochighlight">AGRA</span> BENCH</div>
<div id="" style="text-align: center;">Shailendra Kumar Singh</div>
<div style="text-align: center;">v.</div>
<div id="" style="text-align: center;">Mansi Udhyog</div>
<div id="dbs_judge" style="text-align: center;"><span id="111170000000081217">Ajeet Singh</span>, Judicial Member<br />
and <span id="111170000000057622">Vivek Kumar</span>, Technical Member</div>
<div style="text-align: center;">APL/D129/AGR/<span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span></div>
<div style="text-align: center;">NOVEMBER  3, <span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span></div>
</div>
</div>
<div></div>
<div>
<div id="htmlPreview-101010000000429348" class="html-view generic-font-style html-view101010000000429348">
<div>
<div id="case_101510000000719000">
<div>
<div id="body">
<div id="digest">
<div><b>Mukesh Kumar</b>, AR<i> for the Appellant. </i><b>Saket Bindal</b>, Adv.<i> for the Respondent.</i></div>
</div>
<div id="caseOrder">
<div>
<div>ORDER</div>
<div></div>
<div><b>1. </b>Case called out for hearing on admission.</div>
<div><b>2. </b>Learned DR Sh. Mukesh Kumar, appeared before the bench on behalf of appellant/state.</div>
<div><b>3. </b>Sh. Saket Bindal, Advocate, has appeared on behalf of respondent and took the notice.</div>
<div><b>4. </b>Bothe the authorised representatives have been heard on admission.</div>
<div><b>5. </b>Grounds of appeal and relevant documents annexed thereto are also perused.</div>
<div><b>6. </b>Present second appeal u/s <span class="researchdochighlight">112</span> of CGST/UPGST, Act, has been preferred assailing the impugned order passed by first appellate authority vide which amount of fine and penalty imposed by learned proper officer u/s 130(2) read with section 122 of CGST/UPGST, Act, vide which in a search case conducted u/s 67 of CGST/UPGST, Act, a penalty of Rs. 95,480/- and fine of Rs. 50,000/- total in 1,45,480/- was imposed on respondent firm. It was held by learned first appellate authority that in a search case though department can launch proceeding u/s 73/74 of CGST/UPGST, Act but levying or collecting penalty and fine by invoking powers conferred 130(2)/122 are not sustainable.</div>
<div><b>7. </b>In this second appeal department has challenge the findings of learned first appellate authority confine to amount of fine only.</div>
<div><b>8. </b>We are unable to understand that while department has not challenged the findings of first appellate authority in respect of amount of penalty. How, to the extent of fine appeal can be entertained by this tribunal.</div>
<div><b>9. </b>Thus, this second appeal filed by revenue is not mentionable and accordingly dismissed summarily by virtue of section <span class="researchdochighlight">112</span> of CGST/UPGST, Act.</div>
<div><b>10. </b>Order be communicated to all concerned, as per law.</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div id="footnote"></div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div id="model-response-message-contentr_b40384d4a630928e" class="markdown markdown-main-panel md-content enable-luminous-fast-follows enable-updated-hr-color tutor-markdown-rendering" dir="ltr" aria-busy="false" aria-live="polite">
<div id="body">
<div id="digest">
<div id="headnotes"></div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Railway Construction Services Invoiced as General Construction Without Proof of Composite Works Contract Attract Standard 18% GST</title>
		<link>https://www.taxheal.com/and-vivek-kumar-technical-member-8.html</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashwani Kumar]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Tue, 10 Nov 2026 10:38:04 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Income Tax]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[AGRA BENCH]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[ARSS Sips (JV)]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[GOODS AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.taxheal.com/?p=143583</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Railway Construction Services Invoiced as General Construction Without Proof of Composite Works Contract Attract Standard 18% GST Issue Whether construction services rendered to Railways, invoiced as general construction without structural proofs or billing breakups proving a composite works contract linked to immovable property, qualify for the concessional 12% GST rate under Entry 3(v)(a) of Notification… <span class="read-more"><a href="https://www.taxheal.com/and-vivek-kumar-technical-member-8.html">Read More &#187;</a></span></p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="model-response-message-contentr_c991830436d1b47b" class="markdown markdown-main-panel md-content enable-luminous-fast-follows enable-updated-hr-color tutor-markdown-rendering" dir="ltr" aria-busy="false" aria-live="polite">
<div class="first-token" dir="ltr"><strong><span class="">Railway Construction Services Invoiced as General Construction Without Proof of Composite Works Contract Attract Standard 18% GST</span></strong></div>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="1" data-index-in-node="0">Issue</b></div>
<ul dir="ltr" data-path-to-node="2">
<li>
<div dir="ltr">Whether construction services rendered to Railways, invoiced as general construction without structural proofs or billing breakups proving a composite works contract linked to immovable property, qualify for the concessional 12% GST rate under Entry 3(v)(a) of Notification No. 11/2017-CT (Rate) or are taxable at the standard 18% GST rate under SAC 9954.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="3" data-index-in-node="0">Facts</b></div>
<ul dir="ltr" data-path-to-node="4">
<li>
<div dir="ltr">The assessee, a registered joint venture engaged in construction services, rendered works for North Central Railway during FY 2019-20.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr">The contracted scope encompassed earthwork in embankment/cutting/blanketing, drains, retaining/toe walls, minor and major bridges, relocation of signals/cables/equipment, and ancillary/protection works.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr">The assessee raised invoices aggregating approximately ₹12.14 crores and discharged GST at the concessional rate of 12%.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr">The Proper Officer treated the supplies as general construction services under SAC 9954 taxable at 18% and confirmed the differential tax demand.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr">The First Appellate Authority allowed the assessee&#8217;s appeal, holding the services to be a works contract to Railways taxable at 12% under Entry 3(v)(a) of Notification No. 11/2017-CT (Rate) as amended.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr">The Department challenged the First Appellate Authority&#8217;s order by filing a second appeal before the Appellate Tribunal.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="5" data-index-in-node="0">Decision</b></div>
<ul dir="ltr" data-path-to-node="6">
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="6,0,0" data-index-in-node="0">Inapplicability of Concessional Rate:</b> The concessional 12% tax rate under Entry 3(v)(a) applies strictly when a composite supply of works contract to Railways is conclusively established on record.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="6,1,0" data-index-in-node="0">Failure of Evidentiary Burden:</b> The taxpayer failed to furnish requisite structural proofs, documentary evidence, and billing breakups establishing a composite works contract linked to immovable property.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="6,2,0" data-index-in-node="0">Evidentiary Impact of Invoicing:</b> Invoices issued by the taxpayer described the services as general construction rather than a composite works contract.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="6,3,0" data-index-in-node="0">Confirmation of Standard Rate:</b> The supplies attract the standard 18% GST rate under serial 3(v) of SAC 9954.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="6,4,0" data-index-in-node="0">Outcome:</b> The order of the First Appellate Authority was held to be legally untenable, set aside, and the departmental appeal was allowed in favour of the Revenue.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="7" data-index-in-node="0">Key Takeaways</b></div>
<ul dir="ltr" data-path-to-node="8">
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="8,0,0" data-index-in-node="0">Strict Burden of Proof for Concessional Rates:</b> Taxpayers claiming concessional GST rates under specific notification entries bear the onus of proving complete compliance with all underlying conditions through structural and documentary evidence.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="8,1,0" data-index-in-node="0">Invoice Description Holds Evidentiary Weight:</b> Generic descriptions such as &#8220;general construction&#8221; on tax invoices—without detailed breakdowns establishing a works contract—weigh heavily against claims for specialized tax concessions.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div dir="ltr"><b data-path-to-node="8,2,0" data-index-in-node="0">Requirement of Composite Works Contract Basis:</b> Merely executing infrastructure projects for government entities or Railways does not automatically confer eligibility for concessional rates unless a composite supply of works contract linked to immovable property is explicitly demonstrated.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<div>
<div id="111070000000000133" style="text-align: center;">GOODS AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL , <span class="researchdochighlight">AGRA</span> BENCH</div>
<div id="" style="text-align: center;">Krishna Veer Yadav</div>
<div style="text-align: center;">v.</div>
<div id="" style="text-align: center;">ARSS Sips (JV)</div>
<div id="dbs_judge" style="text-align: center;"><span id="111170000000081217">Ajeet Singh</span>, JUDICIAL MEMBER<br />
and <span id="111170000000057622">Vivek Kumar</span>, TECHNICAL MEMBER</div>
<div style="text-align: center;">APL No. 194 (AGR) of <span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span></div>
<div style="text-align: center;">OCTOBER  30, <span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span></div>
</div>
</div>
<div style="text-align: center;"></div>
<div></div>
<div>
<div id="digest">
<div><b>Mukesh Kumar</b>, Authorized Representative<i> for the Appellant. </i><b>Kapil Arora</b>, CA<i> for the Respondent.</i></div>
</div>
<div id="caseOrder">
<div>
<div>ORDER</div>
<div></div>
<div><b>Ajeet Singh, Judicial Member.-</b> Being aggrieved by the order dated- 16.01.2026, passed by first appellate authority in first appeal no. AD090925149253R/2025 whereby by allowing the respondent&#8217;s first appeal order in original passed by adjudicating officer on 28.06.2025, has been modified by accepting tax liability of Rs. 43,248/- only on respondent while the main demand of Rs. 72,82,446/- has been quashed, department of UP state tax has preferred the present appeal u/s 112 of Central Goods and Services, Act/Uttar Pradesh Goods and Services Tax, Act, 2017 (for short CGST/UPGST, Act) on the direction of commissioner. For convenience hereinafter in the order appellant and respondent will be addressed as department and taxpayer respectively.</div>
<div><b>2. </b>Before narrating the facts of the case it would be beneficial to note that taxpayer did not show his income of Rs. 75,100/- as taxable income, which was detected in audit and accordingly in addition to main demand of tax from construction services, Rs. 43,248/- were imposed as goods and services tax from other income, on taxpayer. To that extent learned first appellate authority has confirmed the order in original and no appeal or memorandum of cross objection has been filed by respondent taxpayer therefore, findings recorded by learned first appellate authority to that extent are not subjected to appreciation by this tribunal and discussion of this tribunal now would be in respect of tax on construction services rendered by taxpayer to Indian Railway a government entity.</div>
<div><b>3. </b>In order to disposal of this second appeal filed u/s 112 of CGST/UPGST, Act facts of the case in brief are that taxpayer is a registered Joint Venture having GSTIN 09AAEAA3620K1ZV and provides construction and other services. Main business place of taxpayer is at house no. A-17 situated at eldeco county, Bijalui, jhasni. Taxpayer provides construction services regarding earthwork in embankment/cutting blanketing side, drains, retaining/toe wall, construction of minor bridges and removal of infringement of signals, cables equipment with other aligned work, construction of major bridges and earthwork in approaches including protection and other ancillary work to North Central Railway in the year 2019-20. For works performed by him to railway he submitted several tax invoices for a total amount of Rs. 12,13,74,088/- on which he paid GST at the rate of 12% through his GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B.</div>
<div><b>4. </b>On verification learned proper officer has issued a SCN u/s 74 of CGST/UPGST, Act to taxpayer that he has short paid tax by willful misstatement as service provided by him comes under head of general construction services SAC no. 995423 and 995424 those are taxable at the rate of 18% GST but he has paid the tax of 12% GST. In such SCN demand of deficit GST was assessed as 72,82,446/- along with applicable interest and penalty. Learned proper officer issued SCN to taxpayer which was replied unsatisfactorily and thus, learned adjudicating officer passed the order u/s 74(9) of CGST/SGCT, Act.</div>
<div><b>5. </b>Feeling aggrieved by the order passed by proper officer as aforesaid, taxpayer preferred first appeal which was allowed by first appellate authority and to the extent of demand of Rs. 72,82,446/- raised in pursuance of order in original, order was set aside, hence this second appeal before this tribunal by state tax department, through its official Sh. Krishna Veer Yadav, Dy. Commissioner.</div>
<div><b>6. </b>We have heard the learned authorized representatives of respective parties and perused the record carefully. The question for determination may be stated thus-</div>
<div>Whether general construction services provided by taxpayer to Indian Railway, comes under the head of &#8220;Composite Supply of Works Contract to Railways and are covered by entry at sr. no. 3(v)(a) of notification no. 11/2017 as amended by notification no. 20/2017 Central Tax (Rate) attracting 12% tax .?</div>
<div><i>FINDINGS WITH REASON</i></div>
<div><b>7. </b>In this second appeal filed by department of state tax, U.P u/s 112 of CGST/UPGST, Act, before the appellate tribunal the core issue revolves around the correct classification and applicable GST rate for general construction services provided for railway infrastructure product by the tax payer. Learned adjudicating officer has held that services provided by taxpayer are not covered in the head of construction of buildings residential or commercial but same are covered with &#8220;general construction services&#8221; which should be assessed under GST slab of 18% not in slab of 12%. In first appeal learned first appellate authority has held that services provided by taxpayer to Indian railway which is a government entity comes under the construction services in relation to immovable property and thus being work Contract services to Railway and are taxable at the rate of 12%.</div>
<div><b>8. </b>Question before this appellate tribunal is only as to whether services provided by taxpayer to Indian Railway such as earthwork in embankment/cutting blanketing side, drains, retaining/toe wall, construction of minor bridges and removal of infringement of signals, cables equipment with other aligned work, construction of major bridges and earthwork in approaches including protection and other ancillary work are work contract services and thus are covered by notification no 11/2017 as amended by notification no.20/2017 or not.</div>
<div><b>9. </b>Thus, work contract description indisputedly includes bridges, toe walls, major/minor construction, signal relocation and earthwork. Unless the taxpayer can mathematically demonstrate with structural proofs and billing breakups that construction services provided to Railways are only in relation to construction /repairing of immovable property, the contract can not qualify for the 12% concessional rate under serial no. 03(V)/(a) of notification no. 11/2017-CT(Rate) as amended by notification no, 20/2017 CT(Rate) dated 22-08-2017.</div>
<div><b>10. </b>Learned authorized representative appeared for department has also drawn our attention to the tax invoices submitted by taxpayer to Indian Railway regarding services rendered by him. In such invoices as noted in the facts it is described the service as &#8220;general construction services&#8221; which are taxable at the rate of 18% until unless taxpayer would not show these services are work contract services. As per SAC (Services Accounting Code) 9954, all construction and works contract services fall under the heading of 9954, however, simply grouping everything under &#8220;construction of immovable property&#8221; ignores the specific sub entries under notification no. 11/2017 central tax dated June 28, 2017 (as amended). Further, taxability of works contract services provided to central/state governments local authorities, government entities and government undertakings like Indian Railways is strictly govern by notification state above. As per serial no. 03(V) of the said notification any composite supply of works contracts other than those specifically carved out attracts a standard rate of 18% (09% CGTS+ 09% SGST). As stated earlier, as per serial no. 03(V) of the notification prescribes a concessional rate of 12% (06% CGST+ 06% SGTS) is only for a composite supply of works contract provided to railway, in this matter taxpayer has not shown supply of services provided by him involves construction services in relation to immovable property and are composite supply of works contract. Therefore, in the present matter services provided by the taxpayer do not qualify for 12% rate under Sr. No. 3(V)(a) and defaults to the standard 18% rate.</div>
<div><b>11. </b>In this way, findings recorded by first appellate authority is that all railway construction services fall under &#8220;work contract services at the rate of 12% GST&#8221; is legally untenable, perverse to record and thus liable to be overturned.</div>
<div><b>12. </b>Consequently, on the discussion above, we are of the considered opinion that this second appeal is sound on the factual and legal aspects and deserves to be allowed. Accordingly, order in appeal dated- 16.01.2026, passed by first appellate authority is set aside and order in original, dated28.06.2025, passed by adjudicating officer is restored as taxpayer has short paid tax by charging 12% GST instead of applicable 18% standard rates on general construction services to Indian Railway, a central government undertaking.</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>GSTR-2A Mismatch and Banking Expenses Do Not Invalidate Genuine Input Tax Credit Claims</title>
		<link>https://www.taxheal.com/and-vivek-kumar-technical-member-6.html</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashwani Kumar]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Sat, 31 Oct 2026 11:46:53 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[GST]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[AGRA BENCH]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[GOODS AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.taxheal.com/?p=143281</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>GSTR-2A Mismatch and Banking Expenses Do Not Invalidate Genuine Input Tax Credit Claims Issue Whether a GSTR-2A versus GSTR-3B mismatch justifies the reversal of Input Tax Credit (ITC) when the differential amount represents valid deferred ITC for FY 2017-18 claimed in FY 2019-20 with proven supply genuineness. Whether Input Tax Credit claimed on banking services… <span class="read-more"><a href="https://www.taxheal.com/and-vivek-kumar-technical-member-6.html">Read More &#187;</a></span></p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="model-response-message-contentr_43bef18b28266b65" class="markdown markdown-main-panel md-content enable-luminous-fast-follows enable-updated-hr-color tutor-markdown-rendering" dir="ltr" aria-busy="false" aria-live="polite">
<div class="first-token"><strong><span class="">GSTR-2A Mismatch and Banking Expenses Do Not Invalidate Genuine Input Tax Credit Claims</span></strong></div>
<h3 data-path-to-node="2">Issue</h3>
<ol start="1" data-path-to-node="3">
<li>
<div><span class="">Whether a GSTR-2A versus GSTR-3B mismatch justifies the reversal of Input Tax Credit (ITC) when the differential amount represents valid deferred ITC for FY 2017-18 claimed in FY 2019-20 with proven supply genuineness.</span></div>
</li>
<li>
<div><span class="">Whether Input Tax Credit claimed on banking services incurred in the course or furtherance of business is blocked under Section 17(5) of the CGST/UPGST Act.</span></div>
</li>
</ol>
<h3 data-path-to-node="5">Facts</h3>
<ul data-path-to-node="6">
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="6,0,0" data-index-in-node="0">Taxpayer &amp; Period:</b> The taxpayer, a partnership firm engaged in constructing residential complexes, faced proceedings for FY 2017-18 and FY 2019-20.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="6,1,0" data-index-in-node="0">GSTR-2A vs GSTR-3B Mismatch:</b></div>
<ul data-path-to-node="6,1,1">
<li>
<div>An ex parte Order-in-Original (OIO) disallowed ITC for FY 2019-20 alleging excess credit availment due to return mismatches.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>On appeal, the First Appellate Authority observed that GSTR-2A reflected ITC of ~Rs. 17.43 lakhs while GSTR-3B claimed ~Rs. 20.82 lakhs.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>The difference pertained to deferred ITC from FY 2017-18, which was disclosed in Form GSTR-9 and claimed under Column 8C in the subsequent year.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>Books of account, tax invoices, and tax payment receipts substantiated the genuineness of supplies, which the department did not dispute.</div>
</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="6,2,0" data-index-in-node="0">Banking Services ITC:</b></div>
<ul data-path-to-node="6,2,1">
<li>
<div>The taxpayer claimed ITC of Rs. 9,184.90 on banking services availed for its business.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>The proper officer treated the credit as blocked under Section 17(5) and disallowed it in the OIO.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>The First Appellate Authority deleted the disallowance, holding that banking services received in the course or furtherance of business are fully admissible.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>The Department appealed both findings before the Tribunal.</div>
</li>
</ul>
</li>
</ul>
<h3 data-path-to-node="8">Decision</h3>
<ul data-path-to-node="9">
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="9,0,0" data-index-in-node="0">GSTR-2A Mismatch &amp; Deferred ITC:</b></div>
<ul data-path-to-node="9,0,1">
<li>
<div>GSTR-2A is a dynamic auto-populated statement, whereas GSTR-3B is a self-assessed return. A mismatch between them requires reconciliation and cannot by itself justify ITC reversal when genuine supply and tax remittance are established.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>CBIC circulars and statutory provisions allowed deferred ITC for FY 2017-18 through FY 2019-20 to be claimed up to November 30, 2021. The claim in FY 2019-20 was proper and valid.</div>
</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="9,1,0" data-index-in-node="0">Banking Services Credit:</b></div>
<ul data-path-to-node="9,1,1">
<li>
<div>Section 17(5) contains no statutory bar or restriction on claiming ITC for banking services incurred in the course or furtherance of business.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>The Department failed to establish that any blocked credit category applied to the banking expenses.</div>
</li>
</ul>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="9,2,0" data-index-in-node="0">Outcome:</b> The Department’s appeal on both grounds failed, and the order of the First Appellate Authority was upheld in favor of the assessee.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<h3 data-path-to-node="11">Key Takeaways</h3>
<ul data-path-to-node="12">
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="12,0,0" data-index-in-node="0">GSTR-2A Is Not Absolute:</b> Auto-populated dynamic statements like GSTR-2A are reconciliation tools and cannot override genuine ITC claims backed by primary books, invoices, and actual tax payments.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="12,1,0" data-index-in-node="0">Protection for Deferred ITC:</b> Deferred ITC pertaining to FY 2017-18 correctly reported in GSTR-9 and claimed within extended statutory deadlines (up to Nov 30, 2021) is fully eligible.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="12,2,0" data-index-in-node="0">Scope of Blocked Credit under Section 17(5):</b> Routine business expenditures like banking charges do not fall under the negative/blocked credit list of Section 17(5) and are fully allowable under Section 16.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<div>
<div id="111070000000000133" style="text-align: center;">GOODS AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL , <span class="researchdochighlight">AGRA</span> BENCH</div>
<div id="" style="text-align: center;">Rahul Kumar Dwivedi</div>
<div style="text-align: center;">v.</div>
<div id="" style="text-align: center;">Shri Shyam Kripa Associates</div>
<div id="dbs_judge" style="text-align: center;"><span id="111170000000081217">Ajeet Singh</span>, Judicial Member<br />
and <span id="111170000000057622">Vivek Kumar</span>, Technical Member</div>
<div style="text-align: center;">APL/25/AGR/<span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span></div>
<div style="text-align: center;">OCTOBER  16, <span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span></div>
</div>
</div>
<div></div>
<div>
<div id="htmlPreview-101010000000428578" class="html-view generic-font-style html-view101010000000428578">
<div>
<div id="case_101510000000717611">
<div>
<div id="body">
<div id="digest">
<div><b>Mukesh Kumar</b>, Authorized Representative<i> for the Appellant. </i><b>Gagan Baghel</b>, Adv.<i> for the Respondent.</i></div>
</div>
<div id="caseOrder">
<div>
<div>ORDER</div>
<div></div>
<div><b>Ajeet Singh, Judicial Member. </b>&#8211; Being aggrieved by the order dated- 13.06.2025, passed by first appellate authority in first appeal no. AD091124901102572H/2024, Sh. Rahul Kumar, Dy. Commissioner, state tax has preferred this second appeal on behalf of state tax department u/s 112 of Central Goods and Services Tax, Act/ Uttar Pradesh Goods and Services Tax, Act, 2017, (for short CGST/UPGST, Act). Vide order under appeal, first appeal filed by the taxpayer/respondent herein has been allowed and by setting aside Order-in-Original, demand of tax, penalty and interest has been quashed. For convenience hereinafter in the order appellant and respondent will be addressed as department and taxpayer, respectively.</div>
<div><b>2. </b>It is admitted or not in dispute that taxpayer is a partnership firm engaged in the business of construction of residential complexes having GSTIN 09ACPFS0362Q1ZB. Department has alleged that in the year 2019-20 taxpayer firm had claimed excess input tax credit of CGST Rs. 10,40,830/- and of SGST Rs. 10,40,830/- as shown such difference in his GSTR-3B and available in GSTR-2A. It was also alleged that taxpayer firm has wrongly availed Input tax credit of Rs. 4592.45/- as CGST and 4592.45/- as SGST which is not permissible as per provision contained in section 17(5) of CGST/UPGST as services received by taxpayer from Oriental Bank of Commerce. On the above learned departmental authorized officer issued SCN to taxpayer firm u/s 73 of CGST/SGST, Act, in which Rs. 10,40,830/- as CGST and Rs. 10,40,830/- as SGST was asked to be deposited as reversal of ITC availed. As per record, SCN was not responded by taxpayer firm despite multiple opportunities given by proper officer. Learned proper officer has passed the Order-in-Original ex-parte against taxpayer by holding that taxpayer firm has claimed input tax credit of Rs. 20,81,660/- in GSTR-3B in excess from ITC available in GSTR 2A. Additionally ITC claimed of Rs. 9184.92/- pertaining to banking services was also cancelled in view of section 17(5) of CGST/SGST, Act. Apart from that Rs. 18,04,427/- were also imposed as interest on tax amount along with penalty of Rs. 2,09,084/-</div>
<div><b>3. </b>Being aggrieved by the Order-in-Original passed by proper officer taxpayer firm has preferred first appeal u/s 107 of CGST/UPGST, Act before additional commissioner Gr.II, appeal (second) state tax, <span class="researchdochighlight">Agra</span>. Learned first appellate authority by conducting further enquiry in the matter allowed the first appeal by holding that taxpayer firm did not claim its due input tax credit for the financial year 2017-18 and such deferred ITC was claimed in the year 2019-20 which is permissible to him as per provisions. It has further held that ITC on banking services which was disallowed by the proper officer is also permissible under law. In such a way first appeal has been allowed in favor of taxpayer firm and Order-in-Original and accordingly demand raised was quashed, hence this second appeal by the department.</div>
<div><b>4. </b>Learned authorized representative for respondent has also submitted a memorandum of cross objection on its title and face but in such memorandum of cross objection no finding of first appellate authority has been assailed. Therefore, same is being treated as reply to the memorandum of second appeal or written submissions made by taxpayer&#8217;s authorized representatives.</div>
<div><b>5. </b>We have heard the arguments of both the authorized representatives and perused the record available in <span class="researchdochighlight">GSTAT</span> portal. In order to decide the second appeal, the point for determination may be formulated as under-</div>
<table class="list">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td class="list" align="right" valign="top">(<i>i</i>)</td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top"></td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top">Whether a taxpayer is entitled to claim deferred ITC for FY 2017-18 in the GSTR-3B in later FY 2019-20?</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<table class="list">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td class="list" align="right" valign="top">ii)</td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top"></td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top">Whether first appellate authority has rightly allowed the ITC of 9184.90 on banking services availed by taxpayer?</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<div><i>FINDINGS WITH REASON</i></div>
<div><b>6. </b>As per chart given in the impugned order itself which is not disputed by the authorized representative of department, in the relevant year 2019-20 in GSTR-2A of taxpayer ITC of Rs. 17,42,911.12/- was available but taxpayer firm had claimed ITC in GSTR-3B of Rs. 20,81,660/- in this way ITC of Rs. 3,38,748.88/- is shown to be claimed as excess one. Learned first appellate authority has also recorded on the basis of materials available on record that taxpayer claimed previous years deferred ITC in the relevant FY which was declared in GSTR 09 of the year 2017-18 and the remaining ITC for the year 2017-18 was claimed in upcoming FY under column 8C of GSTR 09. It was a bona fide mistake that the taxpayer skipped to claim the ITC in the same year in which bill was raised to him and on realizing the mistake taxpayer claimed the remaining ITC for 2017-18 later in the year 2019-20 in GSTR 03B return.</div>
<div><b>7. </b>So far, legality of claiming the ITC belatedly in the year 2019-20 for the year 2017-18 is concerned, learned counsel for taxpayer has drawn our attention to section 16(5) of CGST, Act which provides that notwithstanding anything contained in sub section (4), in respect of an invoice or debit note for supply of goods or services or both pertaining to the FY 2017-18, 2018-19, 2019-20 and 2020-21, the registered person shall be entitled to take ITC in any return u/s 39 which is filed up to the 30?? day of November 2021. The above amendment was introduced by circular no. 237/31/2024-GST and applied retrospectively.</div>
<div><b>8. </b>In para no. 05 of impugned order in an another chart pertaining to deferred ITC for 2017-18 has also been given, which has not also been disputed by the department.</div>
<div><b>9. </b>In respect of point under consideration before us, in case of <i>A2Z Infra Engineering Ltd. </i>v. <i>Union of India </i> 466/109 GST 769/98 GSTL 35 (SIKKIM)/WP Civil No. 25/2024 Sikkim High court has held that in view of inserted section 16(5) in CGST Act by Finance Act, 2024, a taxpayer is entitled for deferred ITC for years 2017-18, 2018-19 and 2019-20 till 30?? November 2021.</div>
<div><b>10. </b>Apart form above, it has been settled by the judicial pronouncements that mismatch in form GSTR 2A and GSTR 3B is a mere discrepancy which forms a reconciliation issue not issuing order of reversal of ITC directly because of GSTR 2A is an informational dynamic reporting tool whereas GSTR 3B is a self assessed return. In the present case and as held by first appellate authority the tax payer firm has succeeded in providing verifiable books of accounts, tax invoices, proof of payment for the proving the genuine nature of the ITC claimed by him. Further, CBIC circular no. 183/15/2022 GST explicitly addresses mismatches between GSTR 2A and GSTR 3B for FY 2017-18 and 2018-19 extended to FY 2019-20 vide circular no. 193/05/2023-GST. It clarifies that if tax was actually remitted to the exchequer and genuine supply occurred, ITC cannot be denied solely due to non-reflection in GSTR 2A subject to verification from suppliers.</div>
<div><b>11. </b>In view of the discussion made so far we are of the considered view that learned first appellate authority has rightly recognized the ITC claimed by taxpayer for the year 2017-18 later in the year 2019-20 and thus, mismatch between GSTR 2A and GSTR 3B shall not extinguish the right of taxpayer to get such ITC. Accordingly, question no. 1 formulated above is answered against department.</div>
<div><b>12. </b>Now we come to the second point of consideration. In this regard taxpayer had claimed ITC of Rs. 9,184.90/- for the relevant year 2019-20 as he availed banking service from Oriental Bank of Commerce, which was disallowed by the proper officer by taking note of provision contained in section 17(5) of CGST/UPGST, Act.</div>
<div><b>13. </b>Learned first appellate authority has held that there is no impediment in section 17(5) of CGST/UPGST, Act which bars a taxpayer to claim ITC for receiving banking services in furtherance of his business. After going through the provisions contained in section 17(5) of CGST/UPGST, Act, we are also in agreement with the findings recorded above by the first appellate authority as department has not succeeded to show that categories of goods and services mention u/s 17(5) in which respect ITC is not allowable to a business entity are existing in the case in hand. Therefore, answer to the second question of determination also goes against the department.</div>
<div><b>14. </b>Consequently, as both the questions formulated in para no. 05 have been answered against department/appellant, this second appeal fails and accordingly dismissed by upholding the Order in appeal dated- 13.06.2025 passed by first appellate authority.</div>
<div><b>15. </b>There is no pending interim application in the appeal.</div>
<div><b>16. </b>Order is pronounced in open court on this day of 16th of October, <span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span>.</div>
<div><b>17. </b>Copy of order be communicated to all concerned, as per rules.</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div id="footnote"></div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Absence Of Dependable Transit Proof And Undeclared Goods Justifies Detention And Penalty Under GST</title>
		<link>https://www.taxheal.com/and-vivek-kumar-technical-member-5.html</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashwani Kumar]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Tue, 27 Oct 2026 10:21:20 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[GST]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[AGRA BENCH]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[GOODS AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.taxheal.com/?p=143019</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Absence Of Dependable Transit Proof And Undeclared Goods Justifies Detention And Penalty Under GST Issue Whether the transporter/appellant is entitled to claim the benefit of inter-State transit passage under Sections 7 and 10 of the Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST) Act, 2017 when transporting undeclared goods intercepted within a state without reliable identity or… <span class="read-more"><a href="https://www.taxheal.com/and-vivek-kumar-technical-member-5.html">Read More &#187;</a></span></p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="model-response-message-contentr_a9f4d96f3085b736" class="markdown markdown-main-panel md-content enable-luminous-fast-follows enable-updated-hr-color tutor-markdown-rendering" dir="ltr" aria-busy="false" aria-live="polite">
<div class="first-token"><strong><span class="">Absence Of Dependable Transit Proof And Undeclared Goods Justifies Detention And Penalty Under GST</span></strong></div>
<h2 data-path-to-node="1">Issue</h2>
<ol start="1" data-path-to-node="2">
<li>
<div><span class="">Whether the transporter/appellant is entitled to claim the benefit of inter-State transit passage under Sections 7 and 10 of the Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST) Act,</span> 2017 when transporting undeclared goods intercepted within a state without reliable identity or destination documentation.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><span class="">Whether penalty and detention under Section 129 read with Section 68 of the CGST/UPGST Act,</span><span class=""> 2017 are sustainable where goods found in transit are completely undeclared and lack genuine buyer or seller authorization.</span></div>
</li>
</ol>
<h2 data-path-to-node="3">Facts</h2>
<ul data-path-to-node="4">
<li>
<div>On August 31, 2025, a goods transport vehicle was intercepted by tax authorities in Uttar Pradesh.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>Upon interception, the driver produced 38 bilties accompanied by invoices and four e-way bills; however, physical inspection revealed undeclared makeup accessories and other goods not covered by the documents.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>The driver initially declared under oath that no other documents existed for the vehicle&#8217;s cargo.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>Subsequent to the issuance of Form MOV-07, the transporter produced 9 additional bilties and invoices, alleging that the goods were in transit from Delhi to Gwalior (Madhya Pradesh).</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>The proper officer rejected the post-detention documents due to non-appearance/lack of authorization from buyers or sellers, absence of reliable business identity or address credentials, mismatch between transport invoices and cargo, and failure of any owner to come forward to claim the goods.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>The First Appellate Authority dismissed the appeal, upholding both the detention and the penalty imposed under Section 129.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div>The appellant filed a second appeal relying on precedent (<i data-path-to-node="4,6,0" data-index-in-node="58">Maruti Enterprises</i>) to argue that transit goods cannot be taxed or penalized in the transit state.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<h2 data-path-to-node="5">Decision</h2>
<ul data-path-to-node="6">
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="6,0,0" data-index-in-node="0">Failure to Prove Bona Fide Inter-State Transit:</b> In the absence of dependable evidence, the appellant failed to establish that the goods belonged to genuine registered buyers/sellers or that the consignment was genuinely destined outside Uttar Pradesh (decided in favor of Revenue).</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="6,1,0" data-index-in-node="0">Failure of Transit Passage Benefit:</b> The benefit of inter-State transit passage cannot be claimed in the abstract without first proving a bona fide factual basis through reliable identity, ownership, and transportation records.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b class="" data-path-to-node="6,2,0" data-index-in-node="0">Distinction from Precedent (<i data-path-to-node="6,2,0" data-index-in-node="28">Maruti Enterprises</i>):</b> Reliance on <i data-path-to-node="6,2,0" data-index-in-node="61">Maruti Enterprises</i> was misplaced because that case involved genuine registered dealers whose documents were produced at the time of interception, with detention based solely on non-generation of e-invoices. In contrast, the present case involved totally undeclared goods and document discrepancies creating potential tax evasion within the transit state (decided in favor of Revenue).</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="6,3,0" data-index-in-node="0">Dismissal of Second Appeal:</b> The findings of the First Appellate Authority were affirmed, and the second appeal was dismissed.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<h2 data-path-to-node="7">Key Takeaways</h2>
<ul data-path-to-node="8">
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="8,0,0" data-index-in-node="0">Burden of Proof for Transit Exemption:</b> Transporters or assessees claiming immunity from local state taxation on account of inter-State transit must establish a complete, verifiable factual trail demonstrating genuine origins, destinations, and ownership.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="8,1,0" data-index-in-node="0">Delayed Submission of Invoices Undermines Credibility:</b> Post-interception generation or submission of bilties/invoices without buyer/seller confirmation or owner appearance will be treated as an afterthought and insufficient to displace detention orders.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="8,2,0" data-index-in-node="0">Applicability of Section 129 to Undeclared Cargo:</b> Carrying completely undeclared cargo without matching e-way bills or invoices directly attracts detention, seizure, and penalty under Section 129 of the CGST/UPGST Act.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<div>
<div id="111070000000000133" style="text-align: center;">GOODS AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL , <span class="researchdochighlight">AGRA</span> BENCH</div>
<div id="" style="text-align: center;">Ghanshyam Null Singh</div>
<div style="text-align: center;">v.</div>
<div id="" style="text-align: center;">Himanshu Verma</div>
<div id="dbs_judge" style="text-align: center;"><span id="111170000000081217">Ajeet Singh</span>, Judicial Member<br />
and <span id="111170000000057622">Vivek Kumar</span>, Technical Member</div>
<div style="text-align: center;">APL/258/AGR/<span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span></div>
<div style="text-align: center;">OCTOBER  13, <span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span></div>
</div>
</div>
<div>
<div id="htmlPreview-101010000000428518" class="html-view generic-font-style html-view101010000000428518">
<div>
<div id="case_101510000000717501">
<div>
<div id="body">
<div id="digest">
<div><b>Saurabh Agarwal</b>, CA<i> for the Appellant. </i><b>Mukesh Kumar</b>, D.C.<i> for the Respondent.</i></div>
</div>
<div id="caseOrder">
<div>
<div>ORDER</div>
<div></div>
<div><i>Brief Facts of the Case</i></div>
<div><b>Vivek Kumar, Technical Member.-</b>The present second appeal has been filed by Sh. Ghanshyam Singh, (Driver/Person in charge of the Vehicle), through the transporter M/S Annpoorna Transport Company, against the order dated 17.10.2025 passed by the First Appellate Authority in appeal No. 09250004 7070TMP, year 2025-26, whereby the appeal filed against the penalty order dated 14.09.2025 passed by the Assistant Commissioner Mobile Squad unit 3, <span class="researchdochighlight">Agra</span>, was dismissed and the penalty imposed by the said officer was affirmed.</div>
<div><b>2. </b>The brief facts of the case are that on 31.08.2025, the Mobile Squad Officer, <span class="researchdochighlight">Agra</span>, intercepted vehicle No. RJ11GB4888 for verification. The driver of the vehicle produced 38 bilties issued by M/S Annpoorna Transport Company, the corresponding invoices and four e-way bills in respect of the goods being transported in the vehicle.</div>
<div><b>3. </b>Upon physical verification, the Mobile Squad Officer found a substantial quantity of makeup accessories and other goods for which no invoice, bilty, or e-way bill had been produced. The goods in question were, therefore, treated as undeclared goods being transported without the prescribed documents.</div>
<div><b>4. </b>Consequently, a notice in Form MOV-07 was issued on 07.09.2025. Approximately one week after the issuance of the notice, Advocate Sh. Mukesh Khandelwal appeared on behalf of the transporter M/S Annpoorna Transport Company and produced 9 additional bilties and invoices in respect of the undeclared goods. On the basis of these documents, it was claimed that the goods were being transported from Delhi to Gwalior.</div>
<div><b>5. </b>The Mobile Squad Officer declined to accept the documents so produced, primarily on the ground that neither the alleged buyers nor the sellers appeared before the authority, nor was any authorisation produced on their behalf. Further, no registration particulars, PAN cards, Aadhaar cards or other satisfactory evidence establishing their identity, business credentials or genuineness of the transactions were furnished. No person came forward to claim ownership of the goods.</div>
<div><b>6. </b>Accordingly, a penalty of Rs. 1255846 was imposed in respect of the goods valued at Rs.1103656. The said order was challenged before the First Appellate Authority, which, vide impugned order dated 17.10.2025, dismissed the appeal and upheld the penalty order. Aggrieved thereby, the appellant has preferred the present second appeal before this Tribunal.</div>
<div>Submissions on Behalf of the Appellant</div>
<div><b>7. </b>Shri Saurabh Agarwal, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, reiterated the grounds taken in the memorandum of appeal. It was submitted that the invoices and bilties relating to the entire consignment were contained in two separate bundles. The driver, by mistake, produced only one bundle at the time of interception and inadvertently failed to produce the second bundle, which was subsequently furnished in response to the notice.</div>
<div><b>8. </b>Learned counsel further submitted that the goods were being transported from Delhi to Gwalior and that the mere passage of the vehicle through the State of Uttar Pradesh did not confer jurisdiction upon the Mobile Squad Officer to detain or seize the goods in the circumstances of the present case.</div>
<div><b>9. </b>In support of this contention, reliance was placed upon the legal principles laid down by the Hon&#8217;ble Allahabad High Court in the case of <i>Maruti Enterprises</i> v. <i>State of</i> U.P 110 GSTL 553 (Allahabad)/ Writ Tax No. 1423 of <span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span> and connected matters, decided on 14 May <span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span>, reported at <a id="anchor_78379.66707562518"></a> . It was argued that, where the goods were destined for a place outside the State of Uttar Pradesh, the action of the Mobile Squad Officer was not legally sustainable. Learned counsel accordingly prayed that the impugned orders be set aside and the penalty imposed upon the appellant be quashed.</div>
<div>Submissions on Behalf of the Revenue</div>
<div><b>10. </b>Shri Mukesh Kumar, authorised representative appearing on behalf of the Revenue, supported the order passed by the First Appellate Authority and opposed the appeal.</div>
<div><b>11. </b>It was submitted that the goods in question were being transported without the requisite documents and that the circumstances clearly indicated an attempt to evade tax. According to the Revenue, the additional invoices and bilties were procured after interception of the vehicle with a view to explaining the undeclared goods and avoiding the consequences of the proceedings initiated by the Mobile Squad Officer. It was further stated by him that the goods in question were not covered by any document and the documents produced later were created as a calculated afterthought. The inordinate delay in producing the bills clearly indicate that the transporter was waiting for issuance of show cause notice and after that bills were prepared as per the description of goods mentioned in the show cause notice.</div>
<div><b>12. </b>The authorised representative emphasised that none of the alleged buyers or sellers had come forward to acknowledge the transactions or claim ownership of the goods. No authorisation was produced by the transporter or the advocate to establish that they were duly representing the concerned parties. Further, no satisfactory evidence was furnished to establish that the alleged buyers situated outside the State were genuine dealers carrying on business at the addresses mentioned in the documents.</div>
<div><b>13. </b>It was, therefore, contended that the appellant had failed to establish the genuineness of the alleged buyers and sellers or to prove that the goods were genuinely being transported from one State to another. The destination of the goods remained uncertain, and the transactions were being shown between the persons whose bona fides had not been established. The Revenue accordingly prayed that the appeal be dismissed.</div>
<div>Points for Determination</div>
<div><b>14. </b>Upon consideration of the rival submissions and the material available on record, the following questions arise for determination:</div>
<table class="list">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td class="list" align="right" valign="top">•</td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top"></td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top">(<i>i</i>) Whether the additional invoices and bilties produced, long after interception were sufficient to establish the genuiness of transportation of the goods in question?</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<table class="list">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td class="list" align="right" valign="top">•</td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top"></td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top">(<i>ii</i>) Whether the appellant established that the goods belonged to genuine buyers or sellers and were moved from Delhi to Gwalior via Uttar Pradesh?</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<table class="list">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td class="list" align="right" valign="top">•</td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top"></td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top">(<i>iii</i>) Whether the legal principles laid down by the Hon’ble Allahabad High Court in <i>Maruti Enterprises</i> (<i>Supra</i>) are applicable to the facts of the present case? Discussion and Findings</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<div><b>15. </b>We have heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant and the authorised representative for Revenue. We have also carefully examined the impugned order and the material available on <span class="researchdochighlight">GSTAT</span> Portal.</div>
<div><b>16. </b>The primary question for consideration is as to whether the goods found during physical verification were covered by the documents produced at the time of interception or by the additional documents subsequently furnished by the transporter.</div>
<div><b>17. </b>It is an admitted position that, at the time of interception on 31.08.2025, the driver produced 38 bilties, the corresponding invoices and four e-way bills. Upon physical verification, however, a substantial quantity of makeup accessories and other goods were found for which no corresponding documents were produced at that time.</div>
<div><b>18. </b>The appellant has sought to explain this discrepancy by contending that the driver inadvertently failed to produce the second bundle containing the remaining invoices and bilties. However, the mere assertion that the documents were available in a separate bundle does not, by itself, establish that the goods found during physical verification were genuinely covered by those documents. Apart from that, there is a situation which also goes against the appellant that in a statement of driver of the vehicle recorded at the time of verification, he has stated that whatever documents he has, have been produced by him and he does not possess any other document.</div>
<div><b>19. </b>In the present case, the additional documents were produced much after initiation of the proceedings. More importantly, the persons shown as buyers and sellers did not appear before the authorities to acknowledge the transactions or claim ownership of the goods. No satisfactory evidence was furnished to establish their identity, business activities or connection with the consignment nor was any reliable material produced to establish that the alleged buyers were carrying on business at the addresses mentioned in the documents.</div>
<div><b>20. </b>The absence of the buyers and sellers, by itself, may not invariably be sufficient to reject a transaction. However, when such absence is considered together with the non-production of documents at the time of interception, the delayed submission of the additional documents, the failure to establish the identity and business credentials of the alleged parties, and the absence of any person claiming ownership of the goods, the circumstances collectively cast serious doubt upon the genuineness of the explanation offered by the appellant.</div>
<div><b>21. </b>The material on record also indicates discrepancies concerning the issuance of multiple invoices of relatively small individual values and the relationship between certain invoices and the corresponding transport documents. These circumstances required a satisfactory explanation from the appellant for which he has not offered any convincing evidence on record to dispel the doubts arising from such discrepancies.</div>
<div><b>22. </b>In these circumstances, the appellant has failed to establish a reliable documentary link between the additional invoices and bilties and the goods found undeclared during physical verification. The explanation that the documents were inadvertently omitted at the time of interception cannot be accepted merely on the basis of an assertion unsupported by satisfactory corroborative evidence.</div>
<div><b>23. </b>We now proceed to examine the contention that the goods were being transported from Delhi to a destination outside Uttar Pradesh and that the Mobile Squad Officer could not lawfully initiate proceedings merely because the vehicle was passing through the State of Uttar Pradesh.</div>
<div>In respect thereof the appellant has relied upon the decision of the Hon&#8217;ble Allahabad High Court in <i>Maruti Enterprises</i> (<i>Supra</i>). In that ruling Hon&#8217;ble High Court has ruled that where origin state and destination state are different and goods are being moved from a third state, the officers of transit state are empowered only to intercept and verification but they are not empowered to launch any proceedings regarding tax effect and they are only obliged to make intimation either to the authorities of originating state or the destination state. After perusing the facts of the case <i>cited Maruti Enterprises</i> (<i>supra</i>) in the juxtaposition with the facts of the case in hand, we are of the view that the applicability of a judicial precedent must be determined by examining the material facts of the case in which the precedent was rendered and comparing them with the facts of the case under consideration.</div>
<div><b>24. </b>In Maruti Enterprises, as the appellant seeks to rely upon the decision, the relevant documents relating to the buyers and sellers were available at the time of transportation and were produced before the competent authority. The mere allegation of detaining and seizing of the goods was non &#8211; production on e-invoices. The buyers and sellers were stated to be registered and genuine dealers in their respective States. The transactions were acknowledged by the concerned parties and were duly reflected in their books of account. Further, the destination of the goods was identifiable and situated outside the State of Uttar Pradesh while in the matter in hand goods detained and seized were totally undeclared one as stated earlier. In case of transportation of undeclared goods via a transit state might also be caused a tax effect in transit state while in case on <i>Maruti Enterprises</i> (<i>supra</i>) can be assumed so.</div>
<div><b>25. </b>Thus, the factual position in the present case is materially different from the facts and question for determination in <i>Maruti enterprises</i>(<i>supra</i>). Therefore, principle laid down in that ruling would not be applicable here.</div>
<div><b>26. </b>In the circumstances and at the cost or reptation we are of the considered view that in the absence of reliable evidence, the appellant has failed to establish that the goods were genuinely destined for a place outside Uttar Pradesh. The claim regarding the destination of the consignment rests primarily upon documents whose genuineness and connection with the goods have not been satisfactorily demonstrated.</div>
<div><b>27. </b>We are, therefore, of the considered view that the factual foundation upon which the appellant seeks to invoke the decision in Maruti Enterprises is not established in the present case. The said decision, on the facts and circumstances as placed before us, is distinguishable and does not assist the appellant.</div>
<div><b>28. </b>It is also relevant that the issue cannot be decided solely on the assertion that the goods were passing through Uttar Pradesh. The legality of the action taken by the Mobile Squad Officer must be examined in the context of the applicable statutory provisions and the circumstances established on record. Where the goods are found without the requisite accompanying documents and the subsequent explanation is not supported by reliable evidence, the appellant cannot claim the benefit of an asserted out-of-State destination without first establishing the factual basis of that claim bonafidely.</div>
<div><b>29. </b>Consequently, and on the touch stone of the facts discussed above, we have also in agreement with the findings recorded by the First Appellate Authority which has not committed any error of law or fact in dismissing the first appeal filed by appellant herein. Therefore, questions formulated in para no. 14 are answered accordingly and against the appellant party.</div>
<div><b>30. </b>Accordingly, the present second appeal is dismissed. The order-in-appeal dated 17.10.2025 passed by the First Appellate Authority, affirming the penalty order passed by the Mobile Squad Officer, <span class="researchdochighlight">Agra</span>, is hereby affirmed.</div>
<div><b>31. </b>The appeal stands disposed of accordingly.</div>
<div><b>32. </b>No order as to cost.</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div id="footnote"></div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div id="model-response-message-contentr_a9f4d96f3085b736" class="markdown markdown-main-panel md-content enable-luminous-fast-follows enable-updated-hr-color tutor-markdown-rendering" dir="ltr" aria-busy="false" aria-live="polite">
<div id="body">
<div id="digest">
<div id="headnotes" style="text-align: center;"></div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Detention and Penalty Under Section 129 Validated for Undeclared Goods Found Without Contemporaneous Documents in Transit</title>
		<link>https://www.taxheal.com/and-vivek-kumar-technical-member-4.html</link>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[Ashwani Kumar]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 26 Oct 2026 12:02:32 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[GST]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[AGRA BENCH]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[GOODS AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.taxheal.com/?p=142968</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Detention and Penalty Under Section 129 Validated for Undeclared Goods Found Without Contemporaneous Documents in Transit Issue Whether detention of goods and imposition of penalty under Section 129 of the CGST/UPGST Act is sustainable when substantial quantities of goods are found without invoices or e-way bills at interception, and subsequent attempts to produce additional documents… <span class="read-more"><a href="https://www.taxheal.com/and-vivek-kumar-technical-member-4.html">Read More &#187;</a></span></p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<div id="model-response-message-contentr_df03c45d61f6de29" class="markdown markdown-main-panel md-content enable-luminous-fast-follows enable-updated-hr-color tutor-markdown-rendering" dir="ltr" aria-busy="false" aria-live="polite">
<div class="first-token"><strong><span class="">Detention and Penalty Under Section 129 Validated for Undeclared Goods Found Without Contemporaneous Documents in Transit</span></strong></div>
<h3 data-path-to-node="2">Issue</h3>
<div>Whether detention of goods and imposition of penalty under Section 129 of the CGST/UPGST Act is sustainable when substantial quantities of goods are found without invoices or e-way bills at interception, and subsequent attempts to produce additional documents fail to establish a verifiable nexus or genuine out-of-state transit?</div>
<h3 data-path-to-node="5">Facts</h3>
<ul data-path-to-node="6">
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="6,0,0" data-index-in-node="0">Vehicle Interception:</b> A vehicle carrying goods was intercepted by the Mobile Squad Officer for verification during transit through Uttar Pradesh.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="6,1,0" data-index-in-node="0">Initial Documents Produced:</b> The person in charge at the time of interception produced certain bilties, corresponding invoices, and nine e-way bills.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="6,2,0" data-index-in-node="0">Physical Verification &amp; Discrepancy:</b> On physical verification, substantial quantities of readymade garments, decorating materials, and other goods were found completely without any invoice, bilty, or e-way bill.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="6,3,0" data-index-in-node="0">Driver Statement:</b> The driver gave a contemporaneous statement confirming that whatever documents he possessed were already produced and no other papers were available.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="6,4,0" data-index-in-node="0">Subsequent Document Submission:</b> After the issuance of notice under FORM MOV-07, the appellant furnished 39 additional bilties and invoices roughly a week later, asserting that the goods were in transit from Delhi to Gwalior through Uttar Pradesh.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="6,5,0" data-index-in-node="0">Lack of Ownership Claim &amp; Verification:</b> No buyers or sellers appeared or acknowledged the transactions, their identities and business activities remained unproven, and the appellant failed to provide reliable corroboration.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<h3 data-path-to-node="8">Decision</h3>
<ul data-path-to-node="9">
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="9,0,0" data-index-in-node="0">Undeclared Goods Without Documents Validly Penalized:</b> It was admitted that undeclared goods were found without requisite documents at the time of interception. A mere assertion that a second bundle of documents existed could not cover the unverified goods.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="9,1,0" data-index-in-node="0">Subsequent Documents Failed to Inspire Confidence:</b> Production of documents long after interception, without buyer/seller corroboration or identity proof, failed to establish a reliable documentary nexus.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="9,2,0" data-index-in-node="0">Transit-State Jurisdiction Distinction:</b> The Allahabad High Court ruling in <i data-path-to-node="9,2,0" data-index-in-node="75">Maruti Enterprises</i> applies only where movement is backed by contemporaneous valid documents, genuine registered parties, and an identifiable destination. In contrast, cases involving undeclared goods and unverified destinations fall outside that precedent.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="9,3,0" data-index-in-node="0">Dismissal of Appeal:</b> The appellant failed to establish a factual foundation for genuine transit through Uttar Pradesh; hence, the second appeal was dismissed and the penalty order affirmed in favour of the revenue.</div>
</li>
</ul>
<h3 data-path-to-node="11">Key Takeaways</h3>
<ul data-path-to-node="12">
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="12,0,0" data-index-in-node="0">Contemporaneous Documentation Mandatory:</b> Validity of transit under Section 129 depends strictly on documents accompanying the vehicle at the exact moment of interception; post-interception document generation is heavily scrutinized.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="12,1,0" data-index-in-node="0">Burden of Proof in Transit Cases:</b> When goods are found without matching e-way bills or invoices, the burden rests squarely on the taxpayer to prove a genuine destination and bona fide transit using verified third-party corroboration.</div>
</li>
<li>
<div><b data-path-to-node="12,2,0" data-index-in-node="0">Limits of Transit-State Precedents:</b> Rulings shielding genuine interstate transit from transit-state interference do not protect transporters carrying unbacked, clandestine, or undeclared goods.</div>
</li>
</ul>
</div>
<div>
<div id="111070000000000133" style="text-align: center;">GOODS AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL , <span class="researchdochighlight">AGRA</span> BENCH</div>
<div id="" style="text-align: center;">Vijay Pal Singh</div>
<div style="text-align: center;">v.</div>
<div id="" style="text-align: center;">Himanshu Verma, JC (IT), JC (IT), IT Section<sup>*</sup></div>
<div id="dbs_judge" style="text-align: center;"><span id="111170000000081217">Ajeet Singh</span>, JUDICIAL MEMBER<br />
and <span id="111170000000057622">Vivek Kumar</span>, TECHNICAL MEMBER</div>
<div style="text-align: center;">APL/257/AGR/<span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span></div>
<div style="text-align: center;">OCTOBER  13, <span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span></div>
</div>
<div></div>
<div>
<div id="digest">
<div><b>Saurabh Agarwal</b>, CA<i> for the Appellant. </i><b>Mukesh Kumar</b>, D.C.<i> for the Respondent.</i></div>
</div>
<div id="caseOrder">
<div>
<div>ORDER</div>
<div></div>
<div><b>Vivek Kumar, Technical Member. </b>&#8211; The present second appeal has been filed by Sh. Vijay Pal Singh (Driver/Person in charge of the Vehicle), through the transporter M/S Annpoorna Transport Company, against the order dated 17.10.2025 passed by the First Appellate Authority in first appeal No. AD090925189850D, year 2025- 26, whereby the appeal filed against the penalty order dated 14.09.2025 passed by the Assistant Commissioner Mobile Squad unit 3, <span class="researchdochighlight">Agra</span>, was dismissed and the penalty imposed by the said officer was affirmed.</div>
<div><b>2. </b>The brief facts of the case are that, on 31.08.2025, the Mobile Squad Officer, <span class="researchdochighlight">Agra</span>, intercepted vehicle no. MP07HB9654 for verification at Shairendra, <span class="researchdochighlight">Agra</span>. The driver of the vehicle produced 35 bilties issued by M/S Annpoorna Transport Company, the corresponding invoices and nine e-way bills in respect of the goods being transported in the vehicle.</div>
<div><b>3. </b>Upon physical verification on 03.09.2025, the Mobile Squad Officer found a substantial quantity of ready-made garments, decorating material and other goods for which no invoice, bilty, or e-way bill had been produced. The goods in question were, therefore, treated as undeclared goods being transported without the prescribed documents.</div>
<div><b>4. </b>Consequently, a notice in Form MOV-07 was issued on 07.09.2025. Approximately one week after the issuance of the said notice, Advocate Sh. Mukesh Khandelwal appeared on behalf of the transporter M/S Annpoorna Transport Company and produced 39 additional bilties and invoices in respect of the undeclared goods. On the basis of these documents, it was claimed that the goods were being transported from Delhi to Gwalior.</div>
<div><b>5. </b>The Mobile Squad Officer declined to accept the documents so produced, primarily on the ground that neither the alleged buyers nor the sellers appeared before the authority, nor was any authorisation produced on their behalf. Further, no registration particulars, PAN cards, Aadhaar cards or other satisfactory evidence establishing their identity, business credentials or genuineness of the transactions were furnished. No person came forward to claim ownership of the goods.</div>
<div><b>6. </b>Accordingly, a penalty of Rs. 2680540 was imposed in respect of undeclared goods valued at Rs.2548166. The said order was challenged before the First Appellate Authority, which, vide impugned order dated 17.10.2025, dismissed the first appeal and upheld the penalty order. Aggrieved thereby, the appellant has preferred the present second appeal before this Tribunal.</div>
<div><i>Submissions on Behalf of the Appellant.</i></div>
<div><b>7. </b>Shri Saurabh Agarwal, learned counsel appeared on behalf of the appellant, reiterated the grounds taken in the memorandum of appeal. It was submitted that the invoices and bilties relating to the entire consignment were contained in two separate bundles. The driver, by mistake, produced only one bundle at the time of interception and inadvertently failed to produce the second one, which was subsequently furnished in response to the notice.</div>
<div><b>8. </b>Learned counsel further submitted that the goods were being transported from Delhi to Gwalior and that the mere passage of the vehicle through the State of Uttar Pradesh did not confer jurisdiction upon the Mobile Squad Officer of State of Uttar Pradesh tax department to detain and seize the goods in the circumstances of the present case.</div>
<div><b>9. </b>In support of this contention, reliance was placed upon the legal principles laid down by the Hon&#8217;ble Allahabad High Court in the case of<a id="anchor_2688.3656803123213"></a> [  (Allahabad)/[<span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span>] 110 GSTL 553 (Allahabad) Writ Tax No. 1423 of <span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span> and connected matters, decided on 14 May <span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span>, reported at .It was argued that, where the goods were moved from Delhi and destined to Gwalior (M.P) in which Uttar Pradesh is a transit state, the action of the Mobile Squad Officer was not legally sustainable. Learned counsel accordingly prayed that the impugned order be set aside and the penalty imposed upon the appellant be quashed.</div>
<div><i>Submissions on Behalf of the Revenue</i></div>
<div><b>10. </b>Shri Mukesh Kumar, authorised representative appearing on behalf of the Revenue, supported the order passed by the First Appellate Authority and dismissal of the appeal.</div>
<div><b>11. </b>It was submitted that the goods in question were being transported without the requisite documents and that the circumstances clearly indicate an attempt to evade tax. According to the Revenue, the additional invoices and bilties were procured after interception of the vehicle with a view to explaining the undeclared goods and avoiding the consequences of the proceedings initiated by the Mobile Squad Officer. It was further stated by him that the goods in question were not covered by any document and the documents produced later were created as a calculated afterthought. The inordinate delay in producing the bills clearly indicate that the transporter was waiting for issuance of show cause notice and after that bills were fabricated as per the description of goods mentioned in the show cause notice.</div>
<div><b>12. </b>The authorised representative for revenue further emphasised that none of the alleged buyers or sellers had come forward to acknowledge the transactions or claim ownership of the goods. No authorisation was produced by the transporter or the advocate to establish that they were duly representing the concerned parties. Further, no satisfactory evidence was furnished to establish that the alleged buyers situated outside the State were genuine dealers carrying on business at the addresses mentioned in the documents.</div>
<div><b>13. </b>It was also submitted by learned departmental representative that, in one such instances M/S Mayur Trends (GSTIN 07ABMFM4648P1ZF) issued a total of ten invoices to M/S D.K. Readymade Store (GSTIN23AOUPG6281K1ZG) each valued at less than Rs. 50,000 reflecting sales of Rs. 2.49.391 via five invoices on 29/08/2025 and Rs. 2,48,320 via five invoices on 30/08/2025, thereby raising serious doubts regarding the genuineness of the transactions and indicating an attempt to avoid the requirement of e-way bills. It was contended that the relevant e-way bills could not have been generated retrospectively for the earlier dates claimed in the documents. This clearly shows the documents produced were fabricated as afterthought justifying backdated illegal transaction.</div>
<div><b>14. </b>It was, therefore, contended that the appellant had failed to establish the genuineness of the alleged buyers and sellers or to prove that the goods were genuinely being transported from one State to another. The destination of the goods remained uncertain, and the transactions were being shown between the persons whose bona fides had not been established. The Revenue accordingly prayed that the appeal be dismissed.</div>
<div><i>Points for Determination</i></div>
<div><b>15. </b>Upon consideration of the rival submissions and the material available on record, the following questions arise for determination:</div>
<table class="list">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td class="list" align="right" valign="top">(<i>i</i>)</td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top"></td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top">Whether the additional invoices and bilties produced, long after interception were sufficient to establish the genuiness of transportation of the goods in question?</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<table class="list">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td class="list" align="right" valign="top">(<i>ii</i>)</td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top"></td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top">Whether the appellant established that the goods belonged to genuine buyers or sellers and were moved from Delhi to Gwalior via Uttar Pradesh?</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<table class="list">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td class="list" align="right" valign="top">(<i>iii</i>)</td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top"></td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top">Whether the legal principles laid down by the Hon’ble Allahabad High Court in <i>Maruti Enterprises</i> (<i>Supra</i>) are applicable to the facts of the present case?</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<div><i>Discussion and Findings</i></div>
<div><b>16. </b>We have heard the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant and the authorised representative for Revenue. We have also carefully examined the impugned order and the material available on <span class="researchdochighlight">GSTAT</span> Portal.</div>
<div><b>17. </b>The primary question for consideration is as to whether the goods found during physical verification were covered by the documents produced at the time of interception or by the additional documents subsequently furnished by the transporter.</div>
<div><b>18. </b>It is an admitted position that, at the time of interception on 31.08.2025, the driver produced 39 bilties, the corresponding invoices and nine e-way bills. Upon physical verification, however, a substantial quantity of ready-made garments, decorating material and other goods were found for which no corresponding documents were produced at that time.</div>
<div><b>19. </b>The appellant has sought to explain this discrepancy by contending that the driver inadvertently failed to produce the second bundle containing the remaining invoices and bilties. However, the mere assertion that the documents were available in a separate bundle does not, by itself, establish that the goods found during physical verification were genuinely covered by those documents. Apart from that, there is a situation which also goes against the appellant that in a statement of driver of the vehicle recorded at the time of verification, he has stated that whatever documents he has, have been produced by him and he does not possess any other document.</div>
<div><b>20. </b>In the present case, the additional documents were produced much after initiation of the proceedings. More importantly, the persons shown as buyers and sellers did not appear before the authorities to acknowledge the transactions or claim ownership of the goods. No satisfactory evidence was furnished to establish their identity, business activities or connection with the consignment nor was any reliable material produced to establish that the alleged buyers were carrying on business at the addresses mentioned in the documents.</div>
<div><b>21. </b>The absence of the buyers and sellers, by itself, may not invariably be sufficient to reject a transaction. However, when such absence is considered together with the non-production of documents at the time of interception, the delayed submission of the additional documents, the failure to establish the identity and business credentials of the alleged parties, and the absence of any person claiming ownership of the goods, the circumstances collectively cast serious doubt upon the genuineness of the explanation offered by the appellant.</div>
<div><b>22. </b>The material on record also indicates discrepancies concerning the issuance of multiple invoices of relatively small individual values and the relationship between certain invoices and the corresponding transport documents. These circumstances required a satisfactory explanation from the appellant for which he has not offered any convincing evidence on record to dispel the doubts arising from such discrepancies.</div>
<div><b>23. </b>In these circumstances, the appellant has failed to establish a reliable documentary link between the additional invoices and bilties and the goods found undeclared during physical verification. The explanation that the documents were inadvertently omitted at the time of interception cannot be accepted merely on the basis of an assertion unsupported by satisfactory corroborative evidence.</div>
<div><b>24. </b>We now proceed to examine the contention that the goods were being transported from Delhi to a destination outside Uttar Pradesh and that the Mobile Squad Officer could not lawfully initiate proceedings merely because the vehicle was passing through the State of Uttar Pradesh.</div>
<div>In respect thereof the appellant has relied upon the decision of the Hon’ble Allahabad High Court in <i>Maruti Enterprises</i> (<i>Supra</i>). In that ruling Hon’ble High Court has ruled that where origin state and destination state are different and goods are being moved from a third state, the officers of transit state are empowered only to intercept and verification but they are not empowered to launch any proceedings regarding tax effect and they are only obliged to make intimation either to the authorities of originating state or the destination state. After perusing the facts of the case <i>cited Maruti enterprises</i> (<i>supra</i>) in the juxtaposition with the facts of the case in hand, we are of the view that the applicability of a judicial precedent must be determined by examining the material facts of the case in which the precedent was rendered and comparing them with the facts of the case under consideration.</div>
<div><b>25. </b>In Maruti Enterprises, as the appellant seeks to rely upon the decision, the relevant documents relating to the buyers and sellers were available at the time of transportation and were produced before the competent authority. The mere allegation of detaining and seizing of the goods was non &#8211; production on e-invoices. The buyers and sellers were stated to be registered and genuine dealers in their respective States. The transactions were acknowledged by the concerned parties and were duly reflected in their books of account. Further, the destination of the goods was identifiable and situated outside the State of Uttar Pradesh while in the matter in hand goods detained and seized were totally undeclared one as stated earlier. In case of transportation of undeclared goods via a transit state might also be caused a tax effect in transit state while in case on <i>Maruti enterprises</i> (<i>supra</i>) can be assumed so.</div>
<div><b>26. </b>Thus, the factual position in the present case is materially different from the facts and question for determination in <i>Maruti enterprises</i>(<i>supra</i>). Therefore, principle laid down in that ruling would not be applicable here.</div>
<div><b>27. </b>In the circumstances and at the cost or reptation we are of the considered view that in the absence of reliable evidence, the appellant has failed to establish that the goods were genuinely destined for a place outside Uttar Pradesh. The claim regarding the destination of the consignment rests primarily upon documents whose genuineness and connection with the goods have not been satisfactorily demonstrated.</div>
<div><b>28. </b>We are, therefore, of the considered view that the factual foundation upon which the appellant seeks to invoke the decision in Maruti Enterprises is not established in the present case. The said decision, on the facts and circumstances as placed before us, is distinguishable and does not assist the appellant.</div>
<div><b>29. </b>It is also relevant that the issue cannot be decided solely on the assertion that the goods were passing through Uttar Pradesh. The legality of the action taken by the Mobile Squad Officer must be examined in the context of the applicable statutory provisions and the circumstances established on record. Where the goods are found without the requisite accompanying documents and the subsequent explanation is not supported by reliable evidence, the appellant cannot claim the benefit of an asserted out-of-State destination without first establishing the factual basis of that claim bonafidely.</div>
<div><b>30. </b>Consequently, and on the touch stone of the facts discussed above, we have also in agreement with the findings recorded by the First Appellate Authority which has not committed any error of law or fact in dismissing the first appeal filed by appellant herein. Therefore, questions formulated in para no. 15 are answered accordingly and against the appellant party.</div>
<div><b>31. </b>Accordingly, the present second appeal is dismissed. The order-in-appeal dated 17.10.2025 passed by the First Appellate Authority, affirming the penalty order passed by the Mobile Squad Officer, <span class="researchdochighlight">Agra</span>, is hereby affirmed.</div>
<div><b>32. </b>The appeal stands disposed of accordingly.</div>
<div><b>33. </b>No order as to cost.</div>
<div><b>34. </b>Order pronounced on the 13th day of October, <span class="researchdochighlight">2026</span>, in open court.</div>
</div>
</div>
</div>
<div id="body">
<div id="digest">
<div id="headnotes"></div>
</div>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
		
		
			</item>
	</channel>
</rss>
