<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><rss version="2.0"
	xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/"
	xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/"
	xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/"
	xmlns:atom="http://www.w3.org/2005/Atom"
	xmlns:sy="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/syndication/"
	xmlns:slash="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/slash/"
	>

<channel>
	<title>retrospective effect Archives - Tax Heal</title>
	<atom:link href="https://www.taxheal.com/tag/retrospective-effect/feed" rel="self" type="application/rss+xml" />
	<link>https://www.taxheal.com/tag/retrospective-effect</link>
	<description>Complete Guide for Income Tax and GST in India</description>
	<lastBuildDate>Mon, 21 Nov 2016 05:11:21 +0000</lastBuildDate>
	<language>en-US</language>
	<sy:updatePeriod>
	hourly	</sy:updatePeriod>
	<sy:updateFrequency>
	1	</sy:updateFrequency>
	<generator>https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.4</generator>
	<item>
		<title>Proviso to section 50C by Finance Act 2016 w.e.f 1-4-2017 has retrospective effect</title>
		<link>https://www.taxheal.com/proviso-to-section-50c-by-finance-act-2016-w-e-f-1-4-2017-has-retrospective-effect.html</link>
					<comments>https://www.taxheal.com/proviso-to-section-50c-by-finance-act-2016-w-e-f-1-4-2017-has-retrospective-effect.html#respond</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[CA Satbir Singh]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Mon, 21 Nov 2016 05:11:21 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Income Tax]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Date of agreement to sell]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Date of Sale deed]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[principle of construction]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[retrospective effect]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[section 50C]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Section 50C retrospective effect]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[stamp duty valuation]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://taxheal.com/?p=17948</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Held when legislature is reasonable and compassionate enough to undo the undue hardship caused by the statute &#8220;such an amendment in law, in view of the well settled legal position to the effect that a curative amendment to avoid unintended consequences is to be treated as retrospective in nature even though it may not state… <span class="read-more"><a href="https://www.taxheal.com/proviso-to-section-50c-by-finance-act-2016-w-e-f-1-4-2017-has-retrospective-effect.html">Read More &#187;</a></span></p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p style="text-align: left;">Held</p>
<p style="text-align: left;">when legislature is reasonable and compassionate enough to undo the undue hardship caused by the statute &#8220;such an amendment in law, in view of the well settled legal position to the effect that a curative amendment to avoid unintended consequences is to be treated as retrospective in nature even though it may not state so specifically&#8221;.</p>
<p id="111070000000000011" style="text-align: center;">IN THE ITAT AHMEDABAD BENCH &#8216;SMC&#8217;</p>
<p id="" style="text-align: center;">Dharamshibhai Sonani</p>
<p style="text-align: center;">v.</p>
<p id="" style="text-align: center;">Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax,Circle-9, Surat</p>
<div id="dbs_judge" style="text-align: center;"><span id="111170000000000142">PRAMOD KUMAR</span>, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER</div>
<p style="text-align: center;">IT APPEAL NO. 1237 (AHD.) OF 2013<br />
[ASSESSMENT YEAR 2008-09]</p>
<p style="text-align: center;">SEPTEMBER  30, 2016</p>
<div id="body">
<div id="digest">
<p><b>Manoj N. Makhania </b><i>for the Appellant. </i><b>Satish Solanki</b> <i>for the Respondent.</i></p>
</div>
<div id="caseOrder">
<p>ORDER</p>
<p><b>1.</b> By way of this appeal, the assessee appellant has challenged correctness of the order dated 21st January, 2013, passed by the learned CIT (A), in the matter of assessment under section 143(3) r.w.s. 147 of the Income Tax Act 1961, for the assessment year 2008-09. Grievance of the assessee, in substance, is that learned CIT (A) erred in upholding the impugned addition of Rs. 15,60,900 to the sale consideration, for the purpose of computing capital gains, under section 50C of the Act.</p>
<p><b>2.</b> It is a case of reopened assessment. During the course of reopened assessment proceedings, the Assessing Officer took note of fact that the assessee, along with a co-owner, had sold certain land at Village Behstan, Surat, on 24.04.2007 at stated consideration of Rs. 45,00,000/- whereas on that day, according to the stamp duty valuation authority, this land was valued at Rs. 76,21,800/-. It was in this backdrop that the Assessing Officer sought to add Rs. 15,60,900/- to the value of sale consideration, for the purpose of computing capital gains, received by the assessee. It was explained by the assessee that though a registered &#8220;agreement to sell&#8221; was executed on 29.06.2005, the sale deed of land could finally be executed only on 24.04.2007 since the land was agricultural land, since the buyer was a private limited company, which could have purchased only non-agricultural land, and since land was required to be converted into non-agricultural land before execution of sale deed. The stamp duty valuation as on 24.04.2007 was therefore, according to the assessee, not relevant for ascertaining whether the sale consideration was suppressed which is what is relevant for the purpose of section 50C. This explanation was, however, rejected. What, according to the Assessing Officer, was relevant was the date on which sale deed is executed. The Assessing Officer proceeded to adopt sale consideration, under section 50C, at stamp duty valuation rate. Aggrieved, assessee carried the matter in appeal before the learned CIT (A) but without any success. The assessee is not satisfied and is in further appeal before me.</p>
<p><b>3.</b> I have heard the rival contentions, perused the material on record and duly considered facts of the case in the light of applicable legal position.</p>
<p><b>4.</b> The fundamental purpose of introducing section 50C was to counter suppression of sale consideration on sale of immovable properties, and this section was introduced in the light of widespread belief that sale transactions of land and building are often undervalued resulting in leakage of legitimate tax revenues. This Section provides for a presumption, a rebuttable presumption though-something with which I am not concerned for the time being, that the value, for the purpose of computing stamp duty, adopted by the stamp duty valuation authority represents fair indication of the market price of the property sold. Section 50C(1) provides that, &#8220;Where the consideration received or accruing as a result of the transfer by an assessee of a capital asset, being land or building or both, is less than the value adopted or assessed or assessable by any authority of a State Government (hereafter in this section referred to as the &#8220;stamp valuation authority&#8221;) for the purpose of payment of stamp duty in respect of such transfer, the value so adopted or assessed or assessable shall, for the purposes of section 48, be deemed to be the full value of the consideration received or accruing as a result of such transfer&#8221;. The trouble, however, is that while the sale consideration is fixed at the point of time when agreement to sell is entered into, there is sometimes considerable gap in parties agreeing to a transaction (i.e. agreement to sell) and the actual execution of the transaction (i.e. sale deed), and yet, it is the value as on the date of execution of sale deed which is recognized by Section 50C for the purpose of computing the capital gain because that is what is relevant for the purpose of computing stamp duty for registration of sale deed. The very comparison between the value as per sale deed and the value as per stamp duty valuation, accordingly, ceases to be devoid of a rational basis because these two values represent the values at two different points of time. In a situation in which there is significant difference between the point of time when agreement to sell is executed and when the sale deed is executed, therefore, should ideally be between the sale consideration as per registered sale deed, which is fixed by way of the agreement to sell, vis-à-vis the stamp duty valuation as at the point of time when agreement to sell, whereby sale consideration was infact fixed, because, if at all any suppression of sale consideration should be assumed, it should be on the basis of stamp duty valuation as at the point of time when the sale consideration was fixed. Income Tax Simplification Committee set up in 2015, headed by Justice R V Easwar-a former judge of Delhi High Court and one of the most illustrious former Presidents of this Tribunal, took note of this incongruity and, in its very first report (http://taxsimplification.in/REPORT.pdf), observed as follows:</p>
<p>6.1 RATIONALISATION OF SECTION 50C TO PROVIDE RELIEF WHERE SALE CONSIDERATION FIXED UNDER AGREEMENT TO SELL</p>
<p>Section 50C makes a special provision for determining the full value of consideration in cases of transfer of immovable property. It provides that where the consideration declared to be received or accruing as a result of the transfer of land or building or both, is less than the value adopted or assessed or assessable by any authority of a State Government (i.e. &#8220;stamp valuation authority&#8221;) for the purpose of payment of stamp duty in respect of such transfer, the value so adopted or assessed or assessable shall be deemed to be the full value of the consideration, and capital gains shall be computed on the basis of such consideration under section 48 of the Income-tax Act.</p>
<p>The scope of section 50C was extended w.e.f. A.Y. 2010-11 to the transaction which were executed through agreement to sell or power of attorney by inserting the word &#8220;assessable&#8221; alongwith words &#8220;the value so adopted or assessed&#8221;. Hence, section 50C is now also applicable in case of such transfers.</p>
<p>The present provisions of section 50C do not provide any relief where the seller has entered into an agreement to sell the asset much before the actual date of transfer of the immovable property and the sale consideration has been fixed in such agreement. A later similar provision inserted by way of section 43CA does take care of such a situation.</p>
<p>6.2 It is therefore proposed to insert the following provisions in section 50C:</p>
<p>(4) Where the date of an agreement fixing the value of consideration for the transfer of the asset and the date of registration of the transfer of the asset are not same, the value referred to in sub-section (1) may be taken as the value assessable by any authority of a State Government for the purpose of payment of stamp duty in respect of such transfer on the date of the agreement.</p>
<p>(5) The provisions of sub-section (4) shall apply only in a case where the amount of consideration or a part thereof has been received by any mode other than cash on or before a date of agreement for transfer of the asset.</p>
<p><b>5.</b> True to the work ethos of the current Government, it was the first time that within four months of the Tax Simplification Committee being notified, not only the first report of the Committee was submitted, but the Government also walked the talk by ensuring that the several statutory amendments, based on recommendations of this report, were introduced in the Parliament. So far as Section 50 C is concerned, the Finance Act 2016, with effect from 1st April 2017, inserted the following provisos to Section 50C:</p>
<p>&#8220;Provided that where the date of the agreement fixing the amount of consideration and the date of registration for the transfer of the capital asset are not the same, the value adopted or assessed or assessable by the stamp valuation authority on the date of agreement may be taken for the purposes of computing full value of consideration for such transfer:</p>
<p>Provided further that the first proviso shall apply only in a case where the amount of consideration, or a part thereof, has been received by way of an account payee cheque or account payee bank draft or by use of electronic clearing system through a bank account, on or before the date of the agreement for transfer.&#8221;</p>
<p><b>6.</b> This amendment was explained, in the Memorandum Explaining the Provisions of Finance Bill 2016 (http://indiabudget.nic.in/ub2016-17/memo/mem1.pdf), as follows:</p>
<p>&#8220;Rationalization of Section 50C in case sale consideration is fixed under agreement executed prior to the date of registration of immovable property</p>
<p>Under the existing provisions contained in Section 50C, in case of transfer of a capital asset being land or building on both, the value adopted or assessed by the stamp valuation authority for the purpose of payment of stamp duty shall be taken as the full value of consideration for the purposes of computation of capital gains. The Income Tax Simplification Committee (Easwar Committee) has in its first report, pointed out that this provision does not provide any relief where the seller has entered into an agreement to sell the property much before the actual date of transfer of the immovable property and the sale consideration is fixed in such agreement, whereas similar provision exists in section 43CA of the Act i.e. when an immovable property is sold as a stock-in-trade. It is proposed to amend the provisions of section 50C so as to provide that where the date of the agreement fixing the amount of consideration for the transfer of immovable property and the date of registration are not the same, the stamp duty value on the date of the agreement may be taken for the purposes of computing the full value of consideration. It is further proposed to provide that this provision shall apply only in a case where the amount of consideration referred to therein, or a part thereof, has been paid by way of an account payee cheque or account payee bank draft or use of electronic clearing system through a bank account, on or before the date of the agreement for the transfer of such immovable property. 30 These amendments are proposed to be made effective from the 1st day of April, 2017 and shall accordingly apply in relation to assessment year 2017-18 and subsequent years.&#8221;</p>
<p><b>7.</b> While the Government has thus recognized the genuine and intended hardship in the cases in which the date of agreement to sell is prior to the date of sale, and introduced welcome amendments to the statue to take the remedial measures, this brings no relief to the assessee before me as the amendment is introduced only with prospective effect from 1st April 2017. There cannot be any dispute that this amendment in the scheme of Section 50C has been made to remove an incongruity, resulting in undue hardship to the assessee, as is evident from the observation in Easwar Committee report to the effect that &#8220;The (then prevailing) provisions of section 50C do not provide any relief where the seller has entered into an agreement to sell the asset much before the actual date of transfer of the immovable property and the sale consideration has been fixed in such agreement&#8221; recognizing the incongruity that the date agreement of sell has been ignored in the statute even though it was crucial as it was at this point of time that the sale consideration is finalized. The incongruity in the statute was glaring and undue hardship not in dispute. Once it is not in dispute that a statutory amendment is being made to remove an undue hardship to the assessee or to remove an apparent incongruity, such an amendment has to be treated as effective from the date on which the law, containing such an undue hardship or incongruity, was introduced. In support of this proposition, I find support from Hon&#8217;ble Delhi High Court&#8217;s judgment in the case of <i>CIT</i> v. <i>Ansal Landmark Township (P.) Ltd. </i>[2015] 377 ITR 635 , wherein approving the reasoning adopted an order authored by me during my tenure at Agra bench [i.e <i>Rajeev Kumar Agarwal</i> v. <i>Addl. CIT </i>[2014] 149 ITD 363  (Agra &#8211; Trib.)which centred on the principle that when legislature is reasonable and compassionate enough to undo the undue hardship caused by the statute &#8220;such an amendment in law, in view of the well settled legal position to the effect that a curative amendment to avoid unintended consequences is to be treated as retrospective in nature even though it may not state so specifically&#8221;. In this case, it was specifically observed, and it was this observation which was reproduced with approval by Their Lordships, as follows:</p>
<p>&#8216;Now that the legislature has been compassionate enough to cure these shortcomings of provision, and thus obviate the unintended hardships, such an amendment in law, in view of the well settled legal position to the effect that a curative amendment to avoid unintended consequences is to be treated as retrospective in nature even though it may not state so specifically, the insertion of second proviso must be given retrospective effect from the point of time when the related legal provision was introduced. In view of these discussions, as also for the detailed reasons set out earlier, we cannot subscribe to the view that it could have been an &#8220;intended consequence&#8221; to punish the assessees for non-deduction of tax at source by declining the deduction in respect of related payments, even when the corresponding income is duly brought to tax. That will be going much beyond the obvious intention of the section. Accordingly we hold that the insertion of second proviso to Section 40(a)(ia) is declaratory and curative, in nature and it has retrospective effect from 1st April, 2005 being the date from which sub clause (ia) of section 40(a) was inserted by the Finance (No. 2) Act 2004&#8217;</p>
<p><b>8.</b> Their Lordships were pleased to hold that this reasoning and rationale of this decision &#8220;merits acceptance&#8221;. The same principle, when applied in the present context, leads to the conclusion that the present amendment, being an amendment to remove an apparent incongruity which resulted in undue hardships to the taxpayers, should be treated as retrospective in effect. Quite clearly therefore, even when the statute does not specifically state so, such amendments, in the light of the detailed discussions above, can only be treated as retrospective and effective from the date related statutory provisions was introduced. Viewed thus, the proviso to Section 50 C should also be treated as curative in nature and with retrospective effect from 1st April 2003, i.e. the date effective from which Section 50C was introduced. While the Government must be complimented for the unparalleled swiftness with which the Easwar Committee recommendations, as accepted by the Government, were implemented, I, as a judicial officer, would think this was still one step short of what ought to have been done inasmuch as the amendment, in tune with the judge made law, ought to have been effective from the date on which the related legal provisions were introduced. As I say so, in addition to the reasoning given earlier in this order, I may also refer to the observations of Hon&#8217;ble Supreme Court, the case of <i>CIT</i> v. <i>Alom Extrusion Ltd. </i>[2009] 319 ITR 306 , to the following effect:</p>
<p>&#8220;Once this uniformity is brought about in the first proviso, then, in our view, the Finance Act, 2003, which is made applicable by the Parliament only w.e.f. 1st April, 2004, would become curative in nature, hence, it would apply retrospectively w.e.f. 1st April, 1988 (i.e. the date on which the related legal provision was introduced). Secondly, it may be noted that, in the case of <i>Allied Motors (P.) Ltd. Etc.</i> v. <i>CIT </i>(1997) 139 CTR (SC) 364: (1997) 224 ITR 677 (SC), the scheme of s. 43B of the Act came to be examined. In that case, the question which arose for determination was, whether sales-tax collected by the assessee and paid after the end of the relevant previous year but within the time allowed under the relevant sales-tax law should be disallowed under s. 43B of the Act while computing the business income of the previous year? That was a case which related to asst. yr. 1984-85. The relevant accounting period ended on 30th June, 1983. The ITO disallowed the deduction claimed by the assessee which was on account of sales-tax collected by the assessee for the last quarter of the relevant accounting year. The deduction was disallowed under s. 43B which, as stated above, was inserted w.e.f. 1st April, 1984. It is also relevant to note that the first proviso which came into force w.e.f. 1st April, 1988 was not on the statute book when the assessments were made in the case of <i>Allied Motors (P.) Ltd. Etc.</i> (<i>supra</i>). However, the assessee contended that even though the first proviso came to be inserted w.e.f. 1st April, 1988, it was entitled to the benefit of that proviso because it operated retrospectively from 1st April, 1984, when s. 43B stood inserted. This is how the question of retrospectivity arose in <i>Allied Motors (P.) Ltd. Etc.</i>(<i>supra</i>). This Court, in <i>Allied Motors (P.) Ltd. Etc.</i> (<i>supra</i>) held that when a proviso is inserted to remedy unintended consequences and to make the section workable a proviso which supplies an obvious omission in the section and which proviso is required to be read into the section to give the section a reasonable interpretation, it could be read retrospective in operation, particularly to give effect to the section as a whole. Accordingly, this Court, in <i>Allied Motors (P.) Ltd. Etc.</i> (<i>supra</i>), held that the first proviso was curative in nature, hence, retrospective in operation w.e.f. 1st April, 1988. It is important to note once again that, by Finance Act, 2003, not only the second proviso is deleted but even the first proviso is sought to be amended by bringing about an uniformity in tax, duty, cess and fee on the one hand vis-a-vis contributions to welfare funds of employee(s) on the other. This is one more reason why we hold that the Finance Act, 2003, is retrospective in operation. Moreover, the judgment in <i>Allied Motors (P.) Ltd. Etc.</i> (<i>supra</i>) is delivered by a Bench of three learned Judges, which is binding on us. Accordingly, we hold that Finance Act, 2003, will operate retrospectively w.e.f. 1st April, 1988 (when the first proviso stood inserted). Lastly, we may point out the hardship and the invidious discrimination which would be caused to the assessee(s) if the contention of the Department is to be accepted that Finance Act, 2003, to the above extent, operated prospectively. Take an example—in the present case, the respondents have deposited the contributions with the R.P.F.C. after 31st March (end of accounting year) but before filing of the Returns under the IT Act and the date of payment falls after the due date under the Employees&#8217; Provident Fund Act, they will be denied deduction for all times. In view of the second proviso, which stood on the statute book at the relevant time, each of such assessee(s) would not be entitled to deduction under s. 43B of the Act for all times. They would lose the benefit of deduction even in the year of account in which they pay the contributions to the welfare funds, whereas a defaulter, who fails to pay the contribution to the welfare fund right upto 1st April, 2004, and who pays the contribution after 1st April, 2004, would get the benefit of deduction under s. 43B of the Act. In our view, therefore, Finance Act, 2003, to the extent indicated above, should be read as retrospective. It would, therefore, operate from 1st April, 1988, when the first proviso was introduced. It is true that the Parliament has explicitly stated that Finance Act, 2003, will operate w.e.f. 1st April, 2004. However, the matter before us involves the principle of construction to be placed on the provisions of Finance Act, 2003.&#8221;</p>
<p><b>9.</b> So far as the amendment to Section 50C being retrospective in effect is concerned, there is no doubt about the legal position. I hold the provisos to Section 50C being effective from 1st April 2003. This is precisely what the learned counsel has prayed for. In his detailed written submissions, he has made out of a strong case for the amendment to Section 50C being treated as retrospective and with effect from 1st April 2003. The plea of the assessee is indeed well taken and deserves acceptance. What follows is this. The matter will now go back to the Assessing Officer. In case he finds that a registered agreement to sell, as claimed by the assessee, was actually executed on 29.6.2005 and the partial sale consideration was received through banking channels, the Assessing Officer, so far as computation of capital gains is concerned, will adopt stamp duty valuation, as on 29.6.2005, of the property sold as it existed at that point of time. In case the assessee is not content with this value being adopted under section 50C, he will be at liberty to seek the matter being referred to the DVO for valuation, again as on 29.6.2005, of the said property. As a corollary thereto, the subsequent developments in respect of the property sold (e.g. the conversion of use of land) are to be ignored. It is on this basis that the capital gains will be recomputed. With these directions, the matter stands restored to the file of the Assessing Officer for adjudication <i>de novo</i>, after giving an opportunity of hearing to the assessee and by way of a speaking order. I order so.</p>
<p><b>10.</b> As I part with the matter, I may make one more observation. The amendment in Section 50C was brought in to provide relief to the assessee in a situation in which the stamp duty valuation of a property has risen between the date of execution of agreement to sell and execution of sale deed, as is the norm rather than exception, but the real estate market is now traversing through a difficult phase and there can be situations in which there is a fall in the stamp duty valuation rates with the passage of time. Such a situation has actually arisen in many places in the country, such as in Gurgaon (http://www.hindustantimes.com/gurgaon/for-the-first-time-circle-rates-reduced-in-gurgaon/story-cjp6e72TeGS9H5jJIALAGP.html), New Delhi (http://www.delhismartcities.com/blogs/high-circle-rates-causing-slump-realty-reduce-delhi-government/), and even in Dehradun (Uttarakhand) (http://www.tribuneindia.com/news/uttarakhand/relief-to-property-buyers-as-circle-rates-cut-50-pc/247805.html) and some other places. It is therefore possible that, at first sight, first proviso to Section 50C may seem to work to the disadvantage of the assessee in certain situation in the event of the word &#8216;may&#8217; being construed as mandatory in application, but then one cannot be oblivious to the fact that this proviso states that &#8220;the value adopted or assessed or assessable by the stamp valuation authority on the date of agreement may be taken for the purposes of computing full value of consideration for such transfer <i>(emphasis supplied)&#8221; </i>making it clearly optional to the assessee, and that, in any event, what has been brought by the lawmakers as a measure of relief to the taxpayers cannot be construed as resulting in a higher tax burden on the taxpayers. Of course, assuming that my understanding of this statutory provision is in harmony with the legislative intention, insertion of words &#8220;at the option of the assessee&#8221; between &#8220;stamp valuation authority on the date of agreement may and be taken for the purposes of computing full value of consideration for such transfer, in first proviso to Section 50C(1), could have made the legal provision even more unambiguous.</p>
<p><b>11.</b> In the result, the appeal is allowed in the terms indicated above.</p>
</div>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://www.taxheal.com/proviso-to-section-50c-by-finance-act-2016-w-e-f-1-4-2017-has-retrospective-effect.html/feed</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>0</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
		<item>
		<title>Not liable to Deduct TDS in case amendment with retrospective effect</title>
		<link>https://www.taxheal.com/not-liable-to-deduct-tds-in-case-amendment-with-retrospective-effect.html</link>
					<comments>https://www.taxheal.com/not-liable-to-deduct-tds-in-case-amendment-with-retrospective-effect.html#comments</comments>
		
		<dc:creator><![CDATA[CA Satbir Singh]]></dc:creator>
		<pubDate>Wed, 23 Mar 2016 05:06:00 +0000</pubDate>
				<category><![CDATA[Income Tax]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[Deduct TDS]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[retrospective effect]]></category>
		<category><![CDATA[section 40(a)(ia)]]></category>
		<guid isPermaLink="false">http://taxheal.com/?p=8186</guid>

					<description><![CDATA[<p>Facts of the case The assessee company has made payment to M/s Holcim Group Support Ltd, (HGSL), a resident company of Switzerland.  The assessee has not deducted TDS in respect of following payments which were on account of training conducted by the Switzerland company outside India. Issue why disallowance under section 40(a)(i) should not be made… <span class="read-more"><a href="https://www.taxheal.com/not-liable-to-deduct-tds-in-case-amendment-with-retrospective-effect.html">Read More &#187;</a></span></p>
]]></description>
										<content:encoded><![CDATA[<p><strong>Facts of the case</strong></p>
<p>The assessee company has made payment to M/s Holcim Group Support Ltd, (HGSL), a resident company of Switzerland.  The assessee has not deducted TDS in respect of following payments which were on account of training conducted by the Switzerland company outside India.</p>
<p><strong>Issue</strong></p>
<p>why disallowance under section 40(a)(i) should not be made ?</p>
<p><strong>Assessee View</strong></p>
<p>The Ld. Counsel submitted that, assessee had made the payment mainly in the year 2009. At the time of making the payment, there was a decision of Hon&#8217;ble Supreme Court in the case of <i>Ishikawajma-Harima Heavy Industries Ltd.</i> (<i>supra</i>), which provided that, if the services has been rendered outside India and not utilized in India then, assessee was not liable to deduct TDS. The amendment brought in section 9(1)(vii) by insertion of an explanation with retrospective effect came into statute only after the President of India&#8217;s assent in May, 2010. Thus, assessee could not have visualized that such a provision would come in the future date. In support of his contention, he strongly relied upon a decision of ITAT Bench in the case of <i>Channel Guide India Ltd.</i> v. <i>Asstt. CIT </i>[2012] 139 ITD 49 (Mum.) and has also filed compilation of various other Tribunal decisions, wherein, it has been held that assessee cannot be held to be liable to deduct TDS when the amendment has been brought subsequently with retrospective effect.</p>
<p><strong>Held</strong></p>
<p>Although, such an amendment has been brought in the statute with retrospective effect but at the time of making the payment there was no such provision under the Act and in fact, the law of the land as laid down by the Hon&#8217;ble Supreme Court was that, if the services has not been rendered in India and such services are not utilized in India then there is no liability for deducting TDS. The amendment has been brought specifically to negate the decision of Hon&#8217;ble Supreme Court. An assessee who has to make the payment cannot visualize or apprehend that in future a retrospective amendment would be brought whereby it would require withholding of tax. Even if the purported amendment has been brought with the intention to clarify the provision but there was no such judicial interpretation that payments made to non-residents for rendering of services in India is taxable in India in absence of any business connection in India or PE in India and in the absence of any clear-cut law, assessee cannot be held to be liable to deduct TDS. It is a trite legal maxim. &#8220;<i>lex non cogit ad impossiblia</i>&#8221; which means that, the law cannot possibly compel a person to do something which is impossible to perform. Thus, we hold that, at the time of making the payment, assessee could not have visualize to deduct TDS when there was no provision under the Act and in fact, there was a already prevailing law laid down by the Hon&#8217;ble Supreme Court that in such a case, no TDS was to be deducted, then obvious conclusion is that on such payment no disallowance under section 40(a)(i) can be made.</p>
<p id="111070000000000011" style="text-align: center;">IN THE ITAT MUMBAI BENCH &#8216;D&#8217;</p>
<p id="" style="text-align: center;">Holcim Services South Asia Ltd.</p>
<p style="text-align: center;">v.</p>
<p id="" style="text-align: center;">Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Range- 8 (2), Mumbai</p>
<div id="dbs_judge" style="text-align: center;"><span id="111170000000003970">AMIT SHUKLA</span>, JUDICIAL MEMBER<br />
AND <span id="111170000000079822">RAMIT KOCHAR</span>, ACCOUNTANT MEMBER</div>
<p style="text-align: center;">IT APPEAL NO. 2357 (MUM.) OF 2014<br />
[ASSESSMENT YEAR 2010-11]</p>
<p style="text-align: center;">FEBRUARY  2, 2016</p>
<div id="digest">
<p><b>Kirit Kamdar</b> <i>for the Appellant. </i><b>Sachhidanand Dubey</b> <i>for the Respondent.</i></p>
</div>
<div>
<p>ORDER</p>
<p><b>Amit Shukla, Judicial Member </b>&#8211; The aforesaid appeal has been filed by the assessee against impugned order dated 03.02.2014, passed by CIT(A)-27, Mumbai for the quantum of assessment passed under section 143(3) for the assessment year 2010-11, on following grounds of appeal:—</p>
<table class="list">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td class="list" align="right" valign="top">&#8220;1.</td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top"></td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top">On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) erred in upholding the disallowance of Rs 33,93,493/-under section 40(a)(i) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (Act), for payment made by the Appellant to its overseas group entity for participating in various training programs undertaken outside India, on account of failure on the part of the Appellant to withhold tax thereon under section 195 of the Act.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td class="list" align="right" valign="top">2.</td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top"></td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top">On the facts and in the circumstances of the case and in law, the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) erred in not appreciating the fact that retrospective amendment to section 9(1) was inserted by Finance Act 2010 with effect from 1st June 1976 only after end of the financial year and was hit by the doctrine of &#8216;impossibility of performance&#8217;.</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td class="list" align="right" valign="top">3.</td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top"></td>
<td class="list" align="justify" valign="top">Without prejudice to the above grounds of appeal, the Appellant submits that payments made for attending induction Seminar, Leadership Seminar, participation fees for ICCA APAC etc. were not in nature of Fees for Technical Services liable for withholding under section 195 of the Act&#8221;.</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<p><b>2. </b>The facts in brief are that, the assessee company has made payment of Rs. 65,47,213/- to M/s Holcim Group Support Ltd, (HGSL), a resident company of Switzerland. The assessee&#8217;s case before the AO was that, the said payment was made on account of participation fees payable for HSSA&#8217;s delegate of assessee-company to various training programmes organized by HGSL during the year. Tax was deducted wherever it was applicable and has been deposited by the assessee. The details of break-up and nature of payment made to Switzerland company as pointed by the AO has been elaborated at Para 5.1. However, he noted that, the assessee has not deducted TDS in respect of following payments which were on account of training conducted by the Switzerland company outside India:</p>
<table class="allborder" cellpadding="4">
<tbody>
<tr>
<td><i>Sr. No.</i></td>
<td><i>Particulars</i></td>
<td><i>Amount (Rs.)</i></td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>1</td>
<td>Being payment towards HARP training fees</td>
<td>1,42,848</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>2</td>
<td>Being payment towards training for management fees</td>
<td>11,24,928</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>3</td>
<td>Being payment towards induction seminar</td>
<td>17,468</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>4</td>
<td>Being HARP training fees</td>
<td>2,64,148</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>5</td>
<td>Being charges for Leadership seminar</td>
<td>6,23,076</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>6</td>
<td>Being fees for harpist workshop at Zurich</td>
<td>1,35,200</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>7</td>
<td>Being fee for leadership seminar at Lausanne</td>
<td>5,78,825</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td>8</td>
<td>Being fees for ICCA APAC 2010</td>
<td>5,07,000</td>
</tr>
<tr>
<td></td>
<td>Total</td>
<td>33,93,493</td>
</tr>
</tbody>
</table>
<p><b>3. </b>The AO, in response to the show cause notice as to why disallowance under section 40(a)(i) should not be made, to which the assessee submitted that, it was under a <i>bona fide</i> belief that payment made to Switzerland company for survives (services-ed) rendered outside India would not fall within the ambit of section 9(1)(vii). Since, here in this case the payment related to the services rendered by a non-resident company outside India, therefore, no TDS was required to be deducted by assessee. This view and belief was stated to be derived from the decision of Hon&#8217;ble Supreme Court in the case of<i>Ishikawajma-Harima Heavy Industries Ltd</i> v. <i>DIT </i>[2007] 288 ITR 408  wherein, it has been held that services rendered outside India will be taxable in India only, if the services has been rendered in India and such services have been utilized in India. In the case of the assessee, the services have been rendered by HGSL outside India and therefore, in view of the principles laid down by the Hon&#8217;ble Supreme Court assessee had not deducted TDS. Besides this, it was also submitted that, explanation brought by the Finance Act, 2010 with retrospective effect from 1st June, 1976 cannot be held to be applicable at the time of making the payment. However, the Ld. AO rejected the assessee&#8217;s contention and after detailed discussion held that, the payment was taxable as &#8216;fees for technical services&#8217; within section 9(1)(vii) and assessee should have deducted TDS. The decision of Hon&#8217;ble Supreme Court will not be applicable or is no longer valid in view of explanation inserted w.e.f. 1st June, 1976.</p>
<p><b>4. </b>The Ld. CIT(A) held that the Explanation to a statutory provision is to remove the ambiguity which may have crept in while interpreting the section/statutory provision. Here Explanation has widen the scope of section to give the true intent of the legislature. For this proposition he has referred to commentary in &#8220;interpretation of statutes&#8221; and decision of Supreme Court in the case of <i>S. Sundaram Pillai</i> v. <i>V.R. Pattabiraman</i> AIR 1985 SC 582 and host of other decisions. After referring to these decisions, he held that explanation is merely an additional support to the dominant provision of the Act. It tries to remove the vagueness-crept in the main enactment; therefore, the explanation here merely qualifies for provisions of section 9(1)(vii). After detailed discussions, he confirmed the said disallowance.</p>
<p><b>4.1 </b>Before us, the Ld. Counsel submitted that, assessee had made the payment mainly in the year 2009. At the time of making the payment, there was a decision of Hon&#8217;ble Supreme Court in the case of <i>Ishikawajma-Harima Heavy Industries Ltd.</i> (<i>supra</i>), which provided that, if the services has been rendered outside India and not utilized in India then, assessee was not liable to deduct TDS. The amendment brought in section 9(1)(vii) by insertion of an explanation with retrospective effect came into statute only after the President of India&#8217;s assent in May, 2010. Thus, assessee could not have visualized that such a provision would come in the future date. In support of his contention, he strongly relied upon a decision of ITAT Bench in the case of <i>Channel Guide India Ltd.</i> v. <i>Asstt. CIT </i>[2012] 139 ITD 49 (Mum.) and has also filed compilation of various other Tribunal decisions, wherein, it has been held that assessee cannot be held to be liable to deduct TDS when the amendment has been brought subsequently with retrospective effect.</p>
<p><b>4.2</b> On the other hand, Ld. DR strongly relied upon the order of the CIT(A) and submitted that the retrospective amendment means that, law was always like that and strict compliance has to be made.</p>
<p><b>5. </b>We have heard the rival contentions and also perused the relevant findings given in the impugned order. It is an undisputed fact that the assessee has made payment to HGSL which is a nonresident company based at Switzerland. The payment has been made for training conducted by the HGSL to its delegates outside India. It is an admitted fact here that neither the services have been rendered in India nor such services have been utilized in India. Out of the total payment of Rs. 65,49,217/-, the assessee had not deducted TDS on the payment aggregating to Rs. 33,93,493/- (on the balance amount TDS has been deducted), on the ground that, such payment relate to services rendered outside India. The revenue&#8217;s case is that, in view of the Explanation brought in the statute by the Finance Act, 2010 which got the President&#8217;s assent in May, 2010 has been brought in the statute with retrospective effect form 1st June, 1976 and such an Explanation is clarificatory in nature which now provides that, the income of a non-resident shall be deemed to accrue in India under clause (v) or clause (vi) or clause (vii) of sub-section (1) of section 9 and shall be included to the total income of the non-resident, whether or not the non-resident has resident (<i>sic</i>) or place of business or business connection in India or a non-resident has rendered services in India. Though, such an amendment has been brought in the statute with retrospective effect but at the time of making the payment there was no such provision under the Act and in fact, the law of the land as laid down by the Hon&#8217;ble Supreme Court was that, if the services has not been rendered in India and such services are not utilized in India then there is no liability for deducting TDS. The amendment has been brought specifically to negate the decision of Hon&#8217;ble Supreme Court. An assessee who has to make the payment cannot visualize or apprehend that in future a retrospective amendment would be brought whereby it would require withholding of tax. Even if the purported amendment has been brought with the intention to clarify the provision but there was no such judicial interpretation that payments made to non-residents for rendering of services in India is taxable in India in absence of any business connection in India or PE in India and in the absence of any clear-cut law, assessee cannot be held to be liable to deduct TDS. It is a trite legal maxim. &#8220;<i>lex non cogit ad impossiblia</i>&#8221; which means that, the law cannot possibly compel a person to do something which is impossible to perform. Thus, we hold that, at the time of making the payment, assessee could not have visualize to deduct TDS when there was no provision under the Act and in fact, there was a already prevailing law laid down by the Hon&#8217;ble Supreme Court that in such a case, no TDS was to be deducted, then obvious conclusion is that on such payment no disallowance under section 40(a)(i) can be made. If the view and contention raised by the revenue is to be accepted that such a law fixing the liability on the assessee is to be reckoned from retrospective date, then it will cause not only great hardship and injustice but also prejudice to the assessee. Accordingly, we hold that, disallowance under section 40(a)(i) on account of any retrospective amendment is wholly vitiated and cannot be sustained. Accordingly, ground raised by the assessee is allowed.</p>
<p><b>6. </b>In the result, appeal of the assessee stands allowed.</p>
</div>
]]></content:encoded>
					
					<wfw:commentRss>https://www.taxheal.com/not-liable-to-deduct-tds-in-case-amendment-with-retrospective-effect.html/feed</wfw:commentRss>
			<slash:comments>4</slash:comments>
		
		
			</item>
	</channel>
</rss>
