Terms not defined in Tax Treaties – Govt should not give explanation – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

By | March 7, 2017
(Last Updated On: March 7, 2017)

Suggestions Clauses 39 and 40 of Finance Bill 2017– Sections 90 & 90A – Clarification with regard to interpretation of ‘terms’ used in tax treaties under Section 90/90A but not defined in such treaties – Concern to be addressed

Under the existing provisions of Section 90 of the Act, power has been conferred upon the Central Government to enter into a tax treaty with the Government of any country outside India for granting relief in respect of income on which income-tax has been paid both under the said Act and Income-tax Act in that foreign country, avoidance of double taxation of income, exchange of information for the prevention of evasion or avoidance of income-tax or recovery of income-tax. Similar provisions are provided in section 90A of the Act in the case of a treaty entered into by any specified association in India with any specified association in the specified territory outside India.

It is further provided in section 90 and 90A of the Act that any ‘term’ used but not defined in this Act or in the tax treaty referred to in sub-section (1) of respective sections shall have the meaning assigned to it in the notification issued by the Central Government in the Official Gazette in this behalf, unless the context otherwise requires, provided the same is not inconsistent with the provisions of this Act or the agreement.

The Finance Bill 2017 proposes to amend sections 90 and 90A of the Act, to provide that where any ‘term’ used in an agreement entered into under sub-section (1) of Section 90 and 90A of the Act, is defined under the said agreement, the said term shall be assigned the meaning as provided in the said agreement and where the term is not defined in the agreement, but is defined in the Act, it shall be assigned the meaning as per definition in the Act or any explanation issued by the Central Government. [ Read How to interpret terms used in DTAA w.e.f AY 2018-19 ]

A tax treaty is a bilateral agreement entered between two countries based on mutual negotiations by executives of respective countries. As per Article 31 of the Vienna Convention, a treaty shall be interpreted in good faith in accordance with the ordinary meaning given to the terms of the treaty in their context and in the light of its object and purpose.

In view of above, the Government cannot unilaterally introduce an amendment in the Act which would override a bilateral tax treaty. In several cases’, the courts have also held the same.

Article 3(2) of the Indian tax treaties provides that if any term which has not been defined under the tax treaty, unless the context otherwise requires, the meaning defined under the Act shall apply. Therefore, the tax treaties already provide a mechanism in such a situation.

Suggestion:

It may therefore be suggested to withdraw the proposed amendments to Section 90 and 90A of the Act.

Without prejudice to the above suggestion, the proposed amendment should be restricted to the terms defined under the Act and should not apply to ‘Explanation to be issued by the Government’. In other words, reference to the ‘Explanation to be issued by the Government’ should be removed.

Source- ICAI Post-Budget Memoranda-2017

269ST – Burning Issues on ban on Cash receipts of Rs 3 Lakh or above -Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Section 94B- Limitation of interest of overseas loans – Issues – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Budget 2017-18 Suggestion- Turnover Limit needs to be increased for TDS section 194A/ 194H/ 194I & 194J

Transfer of unquoted shares – double taxation for seller and buyer -Budget 2017-18 Suggestion

Capital Gain – joint development agreement -Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Gift u/s 56(2)(x) not treated as Income u/s 2(24)? Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Transfer of carbon credits not treated as Income u/s 2(24)? Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Clear confusion of TCS on Sale of Jewellery w.e.f 01.04.2017 – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Exclude pooling vehicles like Mutual funds, AIP’s from section 115BBDA- Dividend Taxation– Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Rs 2 Lakh Interest deduction for house property held as stock-in-trade by builders? – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Partly Cash Expenditure on Asset – entire amount Disallowed ? Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Reduce Tax to @ 25% on LLP, Firms, Firms Coverted into Companies, New companies – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Withdraw Surcharge@10% for total income between Rs.50 lakhs to Rs. 1 crore -Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

271J Penalty on CA/ Professionals – Reasons for removal -Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Indirect transfer tax provisions should be extended to Category III FPI – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

234F – Fee for delayed filing of return – should be Withdrawn – Budget 2017-18 Suggestion

Give Tax Exemption on conversion of warrants into equity shares – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

How foreign tax credit availment in India will be difficult form AY 2018-19 due to reduction in time limit for filing revised return

Define penny stock and expand Exemption list u/s 10(38) – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Clarify whether MAT credit can be carry forward if 10 year period lapsed – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

194IB TDS on what portion of Rent ? if rent increased to 50000 p.m during the year – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Reason to believe to conduct search must be retained – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Foreign Tax Credit Dispute settlement – Clarify rectification time limit & documents – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions

Related Post on Budget 2017-18

Budget Speech 2017-18 -Download /Print

Finance Bill 2017 -Download /Print -Budget 2017-18

Memorandum Explaining Provisions in Finance Bill 2017

Updates  on Union Budget 2017-18

Books on Budget 2017-18

Taxmann’s Budget 2017-18 -Book

Budget 2017-18- Notifications on Central Excise , Customs and Service tax – New Book

Ajit Prakashan’s Union Budget 2017-18 -New Book

BDP’s Customs Law Manual (2017-18 Budget Editon with CD) -New Book

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *