Holding period of new asset purchased
Suggestion on Clause 3 of Finance Bill 2017 – Section 2(42A) – Reduction in holding period in case of immovable property, being land or building or both, to qualify as long term capital asset – Consequential amendments to be made in sections 54, 54B, 54D and 54F
The Finance Bill, 2017 proposes to amend section 2(42A) so as to reduce the period of holding from the existing 36 months to 24 months in case of immovable property, being land or building or both, to qualify as long term capital asset. The same is done to promote the real estate sector and to make it more attractive for investment. [ Read Period of Holding Property w.e.f 01.04.2017 ]
Issues
(1) Consequential amendments for reducing the holding period of immovable property from 3 to 2 years is required to be made in sections 54, 54B, 54D and 54F in line with the proposed amendment in section 2(42A). At present, these sections restrict transfer of new assets purchased for 3 years.
(2) In order to avoid litigation, clarification is required on whether leasehold rights and tenancy rights would be considered to fall within the meaning of “land and building” to avail the benefit of reduced holding period for being treated as a long-term capital asset.
(3) Ambiguity may also arise with respect to flats in a co-operative society i.e. whether shares in a co-operative society qualify within the meaning of immovable property being land or building or both to become eligible for lower holding period of two years
Suggestions:
It is suggested that:
(1) Consequential amendments may be made in sections 54,54B, 54D & 54F so as to enable the holding period of the new asset purchased to be reduced to 2 years from 3 yearsin case of land and/or building.
(2) Circular may be issued/ Explanation may be inserted to clarify that leasehold rights and tenancy rights are also to be treated as falling within the meaning of “land and building” for the purpose of availing the benefit of reduced holding period for being treated as a long-term capital asset.
(3) In order to avoid any interpretation issue, it may be clarified that flats in a co-operative society are also covered within the meaning of immovable property being land or building and are hence, eligible for lower holding period of two years for computation of capital gains.
Source- ICAI Post-Budget Memoranda-2017
Terms not defined in Tax Treaties – Govt should not give explanation – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
269ST – Burning Issues on ban on Cash receipts of Rs 3 Lakh or above -Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
Section 94B- Limitation of interest of overseas loans – Issues – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
Withdrawa ICDS – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions -ICAI
Transfer of unquoted shares – double taxation for seller and buyer -Budget 2017-18 Suggestion
Capital Gain – joint development agreement -Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
Gift u/s 56(2)(x) not treated as Income u/s 2(24)? Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
Transfer of carbon credits not treated as Income u/s 2(24)? Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
Clear confusion of TCS on Sale of Jewellery w.e.f 01.04.2017 – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
Partly Cash Expenditure on Asset – entire amount Disallowed ? Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
271J Penalty on CA/ Professionals – Reasons for removal -Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
Indirect transfer tax provisions should be extended to Category III FPI – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
234F – Fee for delayed filing of return – should be Withdrawn – Budget 2017-18 Suggestion
Give Tax Exemption on conversion of warrants into equity shares – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
Define penny stock and expand Exemption list u/s 10(38) – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
Reason to believe to conduct search must be retained – Budget 2017-18 Suggestions
Related Post on Budget 2017-18
Budget Speech 2017-18 -Download /Print
Finance Bill 2017 -Download /Print -Budget 2017-18
Memorandum Explaining Provisions in Finance Bill 2017
Updates on Union Budget 2017-18
Books on Budget 2017-18
Taxmann’s Budget 2017-18 -Book
Budget 2017-18- Notifications on Central Excise , Customs and Service tax – New Book
Ajit Prakashan’s Union Budget 2017-18 -New Book
BDP’s Customs Law Manual (2017-18 Budget Editon with CD) -New Book