Issue
Facts
-
The assessee-individual was subjected to a search and seizure operation.
-
Pursuant to the search, assessments were framed under Section 153A read with Section 143(3) for Assessment Years 2008-09 to 2013-14.
-
In these assessment orders, the Assessing Officer made additions on account of unexplained credits in bank accounts of concerns controlled by the assessee, as well as commission income on alleged accommodation entries.
-
Prior to passing these assessment orders, the Additional Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Range-4, New Delhi, granted a single, consolidated approval under Section 153D covering seven assessment years from AY 2007-08 to AY 2013-14.
Decision
-
Section 153D mandates an independent application of mind by the approving authority for each individual assessment year before granting approval for search assessments. [In favour of assessee]
-
An omnibus order clubbing seven assessment years together in a single consolidated approval does not satisfy the statutory requirements of Section 153D and cannot be permitted in law. [In favour of assessee]
-
Because the Additional CIT granted a consolidated approval for AYs 2007-08 to 2013-14 without year-wise scrutiny, the resulting search assessments for AYs 2008-09 to 2013-14 were vitiated for want of a valid statutory approval and were quashed. [In favour of assessee]
Key Takeaways
-
Year-Specific Application of Mind: Statutory approval under Section 153D is not an empty formality; the approving authority must independently examine the draft assessment order and material for each assessment year separately.
-
Invalidity of Omnibus Approvals: Issuing a single, mechanical, or consolidated approval covering multiple assessment years violates the mandate of Section 153D and renders the consequential search assessment orders void ab initio.
-
Jurisdictional Defect: Lack of a valid, year-wise prior approval under Section 153D strikes at the root of the Assessing Officer’s jurisdiction to pass an assessment order under Section 153A, making the defect incurable.
CM APPL. Nos. 70510, 70511, 70518, 70519, 70523, 70524, 70537, 70538, 70544, 70545, 70741 & 70742 of 2026
| (a) | It is a case of the appellant that during the course of search conducted at the business premises of the assessee, various bill books were found and seized. During the course of postsearch and assessment proceedings, the seized documents were examined, and it was found that several bills had been issued to BSBK Group, whose premises had also been covered during the search operation. |
| (b) | Thereafter, the statement of the assessee, Shri Atul Kumar Bansal was recorded on oath According to the Revenue, the assessee admitted to issuing bogus transportation bills to entities belonging to the BSBK Group. It is also stated that in the further enquiry conducted by the Investigation Wing allegedly indicated that the assessee was engaged in providing accommodation entries. The assessment proccedigns were finalized by making additions on account of credit entries in bank accounts belonging to Shri Atul Kumar Bansal and commission earned by him on such bogus accommodation entries. |
| (c) | The assessment under Section 153A read with Section 143(3) framed by the Assessing Officer determining the total income at Rs. 1,27,91,68,77.00/-. The Assessing Officer made an addition of Rs. 1,24,75,97,552/- on account of unexplained credits in bank accounts belonging to the entities controlled by the assessee. |
| (d) | Being aggrieved, the assessee challenged the assessment orders before the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) [“CIT(A)”]. The CIT(A) partly allowed the appeals, taking into consideration, inter alia, the assessee’s alleged admission regarding the activity of providing accommodation entries through the purchase and sale bills issued to the needy parties by routing the entries through bank accounts of various concern controlled by him and the Assessee was using all these firms for the purpose of providing sale bills for which he was earning commission. |
| (e) | With respect to the commission income, the CIT(A) observed that the assessee had not furnished documentary evidence to substantiate the commission rate claimed by him at 0.15%. Taking into account the prevailing rates stated to be charged in the market for providing accommodation entries are normally range between 0.5 to 1% as commission. Therefore, the CIT(A) considered the rate of commission at 2.5% assessed by the Assessing Officer to be excessive and consequently, modified the order holding that net commission rate of 0.75% would be reasonable. |
| (f) | Aggrieved by the order passed by the CIT(A), both the assessee and the Revenue preferred cross appeals before the ITAT. |
| (g) | The ITAT disposed of the matter stating approval sought under Section 153B which is consolidated approval for the all the assessment years was not in a consonance with the requirement of the provisions of the Section 153D of the Act, and therefore, the ITAT quashed the entire assessments framed for the relevant assessment years, which according to the learned ITAT was invalid approval under 153D of the Act. |
| (h) | The appeals of the assessee therefore automatically allowed in view of the above. |
“7. After going through this set of evidences available at pages 2-15, we are of the considered view that only one approval u/s 153D was granted by letter F.No.Addl.CIT/CR-7/2021-22/634 and by marking check mark (N”) for each year the approvals are shown to have been issued for each year, but, as a matter of fact, there is no change in the No. of letter being F.No.Addl.CIT/CR-7/2021- 22/634 under which the approval u/s 153D of the Act was issued by the competent authority. Thus, there is no dispute that a composite approval was sought and granted in the case of the assessee for assessment years 2014-15 to 2020-21.
8. Then we find that although at the time of granting approval the ld. competent authority has mentioned that:
“Approval is hereby accorded u/s 153D of the Income Tax Act, 1961 to the draft assessment order as amended in the following case, on the basis of the detailed discussion with you time to time, information available on record, facts mentioned in the Appraisal Report and relevant seized documents perused by you & brought to the notice of undersigned. ”
7. However, the aforesaid seems to be some sort of mechanical exercise only because in the corresponding letter from the ld. AO dated 27.09.2021 (supra) only draft orders were submitted for examination. There is no reference that appraisal report or seized documents were also forwarded. In fact, it is pertinent to observe that vide letter dated 27.09.2021 (supra), the AO had made a request that “online approval u/s 153D may kindly be accorded.” This shows that certainly, the assessment records were not forwarded, what to talk of appraisal report and relevant seized documents.
8. Furthermore, as we examine the approval dated 27.09.2021, we find that in para 3, the ld. competent authority has mentioned as follows-
“3. Copies of the final assessment orders should be forwarded to this office immediately after passing the orders. Proposal for retention of seized material should also be forwarded to this office within time as per IT Act, 1961. Before passing the final order, in case, there is requirement of protecting the interest of revenue, permission u/s 281B from Pr. CIT(C)-3, New Delhi should be taken. Office note, indicating additions in relevant assessment years should be indicated in all Assessment Years, You have certified about perusal and verification of data seized in electronic format through working copies having certified hash values as that of original hard drives/CDs/pen drives/mobile data & any other electronic date. You have also certified to the undersigned that all information available in AIR/CIB/from other Law Enforcement Agencies have been properly scrutinized by you before finalizing the draft assessment order. Please ensure that penalty is levied under proper section of the Income Tax Act, 1961.”
9. The aforesaid observations of the ld. competent authority, as emphasized above in bold italics by us, when considered in the light of the alleged incriminating evidences used in assessments, we find that in fact, no data was seized in electronic format from hard drive/CDs/pen drives/mobile data so as to necessitate making these observations by the ld. Competent authority. The aforesaid observations and directions only indicate that in a perfunctory manner without application of mind post completion of assessment, on the draft orders the approval has been granted.
10. It is now settled proposition of law that the approval so granted without taking into consideration the assessment record, incriminating evidences and the approval not exhibiting the reasons for granting the approval independently on the draft assessment order cannot be sustained.
Reliance in this regard is placed on the decision of the Hon”ble Delhi High Court in the case of PCIT v. Anuj Bansal, 466 ITR 254 (Del). Further we find that Hon’ble jurisdictional High Court in the case of PCIT v. Shiv Kumar Nayyar in ITA No. 285/2024 (Del), dated 15.05.2024, has decided the similar legal issue in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue. The relevant findings of the Hon’ble Delhi High Court are reproduced as under :-
“15. A similar view was taken by this Court in the case of Anuj Bansal (supra), whereby, it was reiterated that the exercise of powers under Section 153D cannot be done mechanically. Thus, the salient aspect which emerges from the abovementioned decisions is that grant of approval under Section 153D of the Act cannot be merely a ritualistic formality or rubber stamping by the authority, rather it must reflect an appropriate application of mind. ”
11. In the case of ACIT, Circle-1 (2) v. Serajuddin and Co. the Hon’ble Supreme Court in SLP (Civil) Dairy No. 44989/2023 vide order dated 28/11/2023, dismissed the Appeal filed by the Department of Revenue against the order dated 15/03/2023 in ITA No. 43/2022 passed by the Hon’ble High Court of Orissa at Cuttack, wherein the Hon’ble High Court had quashed the Assessment Order on the ground of inadequacy in procedure adopted for issuing approval u/s 153D of the Act by expressing discordant note on such mechanical exercise of responsibility placed on designated authority under section 153D of the Act.
12. In the light of the aforesaid, we are inclined to allow the ground No.5 and, consequently the appeals of the assessee for relevant years before us stand allowed and the impugned assessments for the relevant years involved are quashed.”
“13. It was held therein that if an approval has been granted by the Approving Authority in a mechanical manner without application of mind then the very purpose of obtaining approval under Section 153D of the Act and mandate of the enactment by the legislature will be defeated. For granting approval under Section 153D of the Act, the Approving Authority shall have to apply independent mind to the material on record for “each assessment year” in respect of “each assessee” separately. The words ‘each assessment year’ used in Section 153D and 153A have been considered to hold that effective and proper meaning has to be given so that underlying legislative intent as per scheme of assessment of Section 153A to 153D is fulfilled.
It was held that the “approval” as contemplated under 153D of the Act, requires the approving authority, i.e. Joint Commissioner to verify the issues raised by the Assessing Officer in the draft assessment order and apply his mind to ascertain as to whether the required procedure has been followed by the Assessing Officer or not in framing the assessment. The approval, thus, cannot be a mere formality and, in any case, cannot be a mechanical exercise of power.
19. The careful and conjoint reading of Section 153A(1) and Section 153D leave no room for doubt that approval with respect to “each assessment year” is to be obtained by the Assessing Officer on the draft assessment order before passing the assessment order under Section 153A. ”
“22. As rightly pointed out by learned counsel for the assessee there is not even a token mention of the draft orders having been perused by the Additional Commissioner of Income-tax. The letter simply grants an approval. In other words, even the bare minimum requirement of the approving authority having to indicate what the thought process involved was is missing in the aforementioned approval order. While elaborate reasons need not be given, there has to be some indication that the approving authority has examined the draft orders and finds that it meets the requirement of the law. As explained in the above cases, the mere repeating of the words of the statute, or mere “rubber stamping” of the letter seeking sanction by using similar words like “seen” or “approved” will not satisfy the requirement of the law. This is where the Technical Manual of Office Procedure becomes important. Although, it was in the context of section 158BG of the Act, it would equally apply to section 153D of the Act. There are three or four requirements that are mandated therein, (i) the Assessing Officer should submit the draft assessment order “well in time”. Here it was submitted just two days prior to the deadline thereby putting the approving authority under great pressure and not giving him sufficient time to apply his mind; (ii) the final approval must be in writing; (iii) the fact that approval has been obtained, should be mentioned in the body of the assessment order.”
“10. We have gone through the approval granted by the ld. Addl. CIT on 30.12.2018 u/s 153D of the Act which is enclosed at page 36 of the paper book of the assessee. The said letter clearly states that a letter dated 30.12.2018 was filed by the ld. AO before the ld. Addl. CIT seeking approval of draft assessment order u/s 153D of the Act. The ld. Addl. CIT has accorded approval for the said draft assessment orders on the very same day i.e., on 30.12.2018 for seven assessment years in the case of the assessee and for seven assessment years in the case of Smt. Neetu Nayyar. It is also pertinent in this regard to refer to pages 68 and 69 of the paper book which contains information obtained by Smt. Neetu Nayyar from Central Public Information Officer who is none other than the ld. Addl. Commissioner of Income-tax, Central Range-S, New Delhi, under Right to Information Act, wherein, it reveals that the ld. Addl. CIT had granted approval for 43 cases on 30.12.2018 itself. This fact is not in dispute before us. Of these 43 cases, as evident from page 36 of the paper book which contains the approval u/s 153D, 14 cases pertained to the assessee herein and Smt. Neetu Nayyar. The remaining cases may belong to some other assessees, which information is not available before us. In any event, whether it is humanly possible for an approving authority like ld. Addl. CIT to grant judicious approval u/s 153D of the Act for 43 cases on a single day is the subject matter of dispute before us. Further, section 153D provides that approval has to be granted for each of the assessment year whereas, in the instant case, the ld. Addl. CIT has granted a single approval for all assessment years put together.”
| (i) | Whether in the facts of the case, one common approval for different Assessment Years granted by the Additional Commissioner of Income Tax was contrary to law? |
| (ii) | In case the answer to the first question is in the affirmative, whether the lapse is procedural or substantial warranting annulment of the assessment proceedings?” |

