I. Writ petition against GST demand order is dismissed as assessee failed to avail personal hearing opportunity; appeal is the proper remedy. II. Challenge to GST limitation extension notification is stayed pending Supreme Court’s decision. I. GST Demand Order Not Subject to Writ Intervention When Personal Hearing Opportunity Was Granted But Not Availed. Issue: Whether… Read More »
GST demand order set aside and remanded because it was cryptic, template-based, and failed to consider the petitioner’s reply to the SCN. Issue: Whether a GST adjudication order passed under Section 73 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST Act, 2017), confirming a demand, is valid if it is “cryptic” and “template-based,”… Read More »
GST appeal restored and bank account release directed due to marginal delay, portal access difficulty, and non-constituted appellate tribunal. Issue: When an assessee’s appeal against an assessment order under Section 73 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST Act, 2017), is dismissed by the appellate authority solely due to a marginal delay… Read More »
SLP dismissed: Excess stock found in search/inspection triggers Sections 73/74, not Section 130 of CGST Act. Issue: Whether a Special Leave Petition (SLP) filed by the revenue challenging a High Court judgment, which held that if excess stock is found during a search or inspection, proceedings should be initiated under Sections 73/74 of the Central… Read More »
Appeal to appellate authority restored due to condoned 192-day delay, caused by proprietor’s ill-health and reliance on accountant unaware of proceedings. Issue: Whether a High Court should set aside an appellate order dismissing an appeal on grounds of limitation (192 days delay) and condone the delay, thereby restoring the appeal for hearing on merits, when… Read More »
GST orders quashed and remanded due to SCN upload in wrong tab and denied hearing, as opportunity of hearing and proper notice service are mandatory. Issue: Whether an assessment order passed under Section 74 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST Act, 2017), and a subsequent appellate order upholding it, are valid… Read More »
I. GST demand order set aside and remanded because it was passed during the pendency of a writ petition challenging the underlying SCN and related notifications, effectively denying an opportunity to reply. II. Challenge to GST limitation extension notifications is stayed pending Supreme Court’s decision. I. GST Demand Order Set Aside for Being Passed During… Read More »
I. GST demand order is not subject to writ interference if the assessee was granted a personal hearing opportunity but failed to avail it; appeal is the proper remedy. II. Challenge to GST limitation extension notification is stayed pending Supreme Court’s decision. I. GST Demand Order Not Subject to Writ Intervention When Personal Hearing Opportunity… Read More »
I. GST demand order set aside due to non-service of SCN on a taxpayer with cancelled registration, denying reply and hearing. II. Challenge to GST limitation extension notification is stayed pending Supreme Court’s decision. I. GST Demand Order Set Aside Due to Non-Service of SCN on Taxpayer with Cancelled Registration. Issue: Whether a GST demand… Read More »
I. GST demand order set aside and remanded due to denial of proper hearing opportunity. II. Challenge to GST limitation extension notification is stayed pending Supreme Court’s decision. I. GST Demand Order Set Aside and Remanded Due to Denial of Proper Hearing Opportunity. Issue: Whether a GST demand order passed under Section 73 of the… Read More »