Appellate authority cannot dismiss appeal for pre-deposit shortfall without hearing or considering investigation deposits.
Issue
Whether the Commissioner (Appeals) is justified in rejecting an appeal under Section 107 of the CGST/MGST Act, 2017 for alleged non-compliance with the statutory pre-deposit requirement without issuing a defect memo, granting a hearing, or considering substantial amounts already deposited and appropriated during the investigation.
Facts
-
The petitioner-assessee, engaged in the trading of cotton, was investigated by DGGI Nashik regarding alleged non-payment of GST under the Reverse Charge Mechanism (RCM) on rock cotton purchased from agriculturists.
-
Following a search operation, the tax liability was quantified at Rs. 14.77 crores, a Show Cause Notice (SCN) was issued, and the demand was confirmed in adjudication.
-
During the course of the investigation, the petitioner deposited Rs. 1.50 crores, which was subsequently appropriated toward the demand.
-
The petitioner filed an electronic appeal before the Commissioner (Appeals) against the demand order.
-
The Commissioner (Appeals) summarily rejected the appeal for alleged non-compliance with the statutory pre-deposit requirement without issuing any defect memo or notice, without affording an opportunity of hearing, and without accounting for the Rs. 1.50 crores deposited during the investigation.
Decision
-
The appellate authority failed to issue a defect memo, serve any notice, or afford an opportunity of personal hearing before dismissing the appeal on technical grounds of pre-deposit non-compliance. [In favour of assessee/matter remanded]
-
Under settled principles of law, an appellate authority is obligated to grant the appellant an opportunity to cure any alleged pre-deposit defect or shortfall before rejecting an appeal. [In favour of assessee/matter remanded]
-
The Rs. 1.50 crores deposited by the petitioner during the investigation—which was later appropriated—far exceeded the statutory pre-deposit threshold under Section 107(6) and ought to have been considered. [In favour of assessee/matter remanded]
-
Consequently, the impugned appellate order was quashed, and the matter was remitted back to the Commissioner (Appeals) for a fresh hearing on the pre-deposit issue, keeping all questions on the merits of the dispute open. [In favour of assessee/matter remanded]
Key Takeaways
-
Adjustment of Investigation Deposits Towards Pre-Deposit: Amounts deposited and appropriated during investigation proceedings (including via Form DRC-03/DRC-03A) must be factored in while verifying compliance with the mandatory pre-deposit under Section 107(6) of the CGST Act.
-
Mandatory Opportunity to Cure Defects: An appeal cannot be dismissed in limine for alleged non-payment or shortfall of pre-deposit without first issuing a formal defect memo/notice and granting a personal hearing to the taxpayer.
-
Preservation of Substantive Merits: Where an appellate order is set aside for procedural violations at the admission/pre-deposit stage, courts routinely remand the matter for fresh verification while keeping all substantive merits open for adjudication.
HIGH COURT OF BOMBAY
Bhagyoday Agro Industies
v.
Commissioner (Appeals) CGST & Central Excise
M.S. Karnik and Sandesh D. Patil, JJ.
WRIT PETITION NO. 9256 OF 2026†
OCTOBER 12, 2026
Parth Parikh, Ms. Samikshya Chatur and Yash Prakash for the Petitioner. Jitendra B. Mishra, Ms. Sangeeta Yadav, Umesh Gupta and A.R. Deolekar, AGP for the Respondent.
JUDGMENT
Sandesh D. Patil, J. – By this Petition, the Petitioner is challenging the Order dated 19th May, 2026, passed in the proceedings filed before the Office of Commissioner (Appeals), CGST and Central Excise, Nashik.
2. The Petitioner is registered under the CGST Act and is engaged in the trading of cotton. As per the information gathered by the Officers of the Directorate General of Goods and Service Tax Intelligence Nashik Region Unit, regarding non-payment of GST by the Appellant under the Reverse Charge Mechanism (RCM) on the purchase of rock cotton from agriculturists, a search was conducted by the Officers under Section 67 of the CGST act 2017 (CGST Act). The GST liability under RCM on purchase of rock Cotton from agriculturists was quantified to the tune of ₹14,77,57,828/-. Accordingly, the Appellant was issued show cause notice. The Adjudicating Authority passed Order dated 28th October, 2024, confirming the demand of ₹14,77,57,828/- and had appropriate tax amount of ₹1,50,00,000/-.
3. Being aggrieved and dissatisfied with the Order passed by the Adjudicating Officer, the Applicant has preferred Appeal electronically on 3rd February, 2025. It is the contention of the Appellant that the Appellate Authority on 19th May, 2026, rejected the Appeal filed by the Appellant and confirmed the Order in original passed by the Additional Commissioner, CGST & CX Aurangabad.
4. The Appellant has challenged the impugned Order passed by the Commissioner, CGST & CX dated 19th May, 2026, on the ground that the impugned Order does not take into consideration the fact that an amount of ₹1,50,00,000/-was deposited by the Petitioner during the course of the investigation, which was appropriated against the demand. The Petitioner contended that despite such adjustment, Respondent No.1 arbitrarily proceeded to reject the Appeal filed by the Petitioner without considering that the amount already deposited by the Petitioner during the course of investigation far exceeded the statutory pre-deposit amount as per Circular dated 11th July, 2024.
5. The learned Counsel appearing for the Petitioner stated that the impugned Order is passed in a gross violation of principles of natural justice. No defect memo, notice or opportunity was granted before dismissing the Appeal.
6. The learned Counsel appearing for the Revenue supported the Judgment and Order. The learned Counsel appearing for the Revenue stated that the impugned Judgment and Order does not suffer from any error and that the Appeal was rightly rejected.
7. We have perused the impugned Order dated 19th May, 2026. It is not in dispute that no defect memo, notice or opportunity was granted to the Petitioner before dismissing the Appeal. The Petitioner had already deposited an amount of ₹1,50,00,000/- during the course of investigation. This amount far exceeded the statutory amount required to be deposited before filing of the Appeal. The Appellate Authority ought to have applied the well settled principle that when an Appeal is to be dismissed for adding a shortfall in pre- deposit, the Appellant has to be given a no defect memo, notice or opportunity of hearing before dismissal of the appeal. The Petitioner is definitely required to be given an opportunity to satisfy the shortfall. In this case, the contention of the Petitioner that the amount of Rs.1,50,00,000/- was already deposited is also a relevant fact, which is not considered by the Appellate Authority. In this premise, we have no hesitation to set aside the impugned Judgment and Order dated 19th May 2026, passed by the Commissioner (Appeals), CGST and Central Excise, Nashik passed in proceedings bearing No.NSK/GST/000/APPL/52/2026–27 dated 19th May, 2025. Hence the following Order.
ORDER
| (i) | The Writ Petition is allowed. |
| (ii) | The Order dated 19th May, 2026, passed by the learned Commissioner (Appeals) CTST & Central Excise, Nashik in proceeding bearing No.NSK/GSP/000/APPL/52/2026-2027, is quashed and set aside. |
| (iii) | The Commissioner (Appeals), CGST & Central Excise, Nashik, is directed to give a fresh hearing to the Petitioner, especially on the point of pre-deposit of the amount. |
| (iv) | The Commissioner (Appeals), CGST & Central Excise, Nashik, to decide the said proceedings within a period of 12 weeks from the date of producing the Order passed by this Court before him/her. |
| (v) | The Authorized Representative of the Petitioner to remain present before the Authority on 21 st October, 2026 at 11.00 a.m., after which the Appellate Authority will commence further proceedings. |
8. All contentions of the parties on merits are kept open.
9. Writ Petition No.9256 of 2026 is disposed of accordingly.

