Provisional attachment order under Benami Act cannot be sustained without establishing a direct nexus between prior capital introduction and subsequent property acquisition.

By | November 17, 2026
Provisional attachment order under Benami Act cannot be sustained without establishing a direct nexus between prior capital introduction and subsequent property acquisition.

Issue

Whether the provisional attachment of a property under the Prohibition of Benami Transactions Act, 1988, can be sustained when the Revenue fails to establish a direct factual nexus between share premium funds raised years prior and the subsequent acquisition of the property, and where the company cogently explains the legitimate source of funds through the liquidation of its investments and mutual funds.

Facts

  • The respondent-company acquired a duplex apartment in 2015 for approximately Rs. 30 crores.
  • The appellant-Department alleged that the acquisition was a benami transaction, claiming the company had allotted shares at a high premium in 2006-07 to raise about Rs. 69.70 crores via accommodation entries.
  • Income-tax proceedings included statements under Section 131 from an entry operator and a witness admitting the use of companies to route unaccounted money.
  • A 2018 search at the respondent’s premises led to a statement by a director claiming to be a dummy and stating the company had no business to fund the purchase.
  • The Initiating Officer relied on this material to form a belief of a benami transaction, passed a Provisional Attachment Order over the property, and referred the matter to the Adjudicating Authority.
  • The Adjudicating Authority declined to confirm the provisional attachment, holding that the capital introduction occurred 8 to 9 years prior to the property purchase with no evidence establishing a nexus.

Decision

  • An incorrect or omitted statutory reference does not render an order illegal if the facts disclosed fulfill the requirements of a benami transaction under the applicable provisions.
  • Evidence collected during income-tax proceedings can be relied upon by the Department alongside other gathered evidence.
  • The Department failed to collect evidence showing that the share premium raised in 2006-07 was actually utilized for the purchase of the property 8 to 9 years later.
  • The Department failed to establish that the transaction was executed for the future benefit of a beneficial owner, which is essential to make out a case of a benami transaction.
  • The respondent-company provided a specific and cogent explanation that the funds deployed for the purchase were generated through the liquidation of its investments and mutual funds.
  • The findings of the Adjudicating Authority on merits were accepted without interference, and the appeal was dismissed.

Key Takeaways

  • Requirement of Nexus: A significant time gap between alleged tainted capital infusion (such as share premium) and asset acquisition requires clear, concrete evidence linking the two funds; mere suspicion or remote temporal connection is insufficient.
  • Source of Funds: If a respondent company successfully demonstrates a legitimate source of funds—such as through the liquidation of prior investments and mutual funds—the burden shifts back to the Department to disprove it with tangible evidence.
  • Beneficial Interest: Establishing a benami transaction requires concrete proof that the transaction was conducted for the immediate or future benefit of a third-party beneficial owner.
  • Procedural Irregularity vs. Substance: A technical error or omission in citing statutory provisions does not automatically invalidate an order if the underlying facts substantiate the action, though the case must still succeed on its substantive merits.
APPELLATE TRIBUNAL SAFEMA , NEW DELHI
DCIT, Mumbai
v.
Aachman Vanijya (P.) Ltd.
Justice Munishwar Nath Bhandari, Chairman
and V. Anandarajan, Member
MP-PBPT No. 2912 (MUM) of 2023 (Stay)
FPA-PBPT No. 2495 (MUM) of 2023
SEPTEMBER  29, 2026
Manmeet S. Arora, S.P.P, Ms. Jahanvi Kapoor and Shourya Sharma, Advs. for the Appellant. Ashwani Taneja, Ms. Gunjan Chauhan, Preet Kashish, Advs., Ashish Tandon and Pranav Goyal, CAs for the Respondent.
ORDER
1. This appeal has been preferred under Section 46 of the Prohibition of Benami Transactions Act, 1988 (in short “the Act of 1988”), to challenge the order dated 14.09.2022 passed by the Adjudicating Authority denying confirmation of the Provisional Attachment Order dated 24.09.2021 while rejecting the reference.
Brief facts of the case:
2. It is a case where the benamidar company, M/s Aachman Vanijya Pvt. Ltd., was incorporated on 24.07.1995. A Duplex Apartment No.2, 8?? and 9th floors at 7, Marine Drive, CS 406, Malabar Hill, Mumbai was purchased from M/s Aurum Platz Pvt. Ltd. for a consideration of Rs.30 Crores on 29.12.2015. It was taken to be a benami transaction based on the fact that M/s Aachman Vanijya Pvt. Ltd. had allotted its shares at a high premium on 31.08.2006 and 31.03.2007. It was taken to be a source of consideration paid by the benamidar for purchase of the property. It was for the reason that 7,04,000 shares having face value of Rs.10/- were allotted at a premium of Rs.990/- generating share premium of Rs.69,69,60,000/-. It was taken to be nothing but an effort to provide accommodation entries to the entities managed and controlled by one Shri Jivendra Mishra, who is said to be an entry operator from Kolkata. The statement of Shri Jivendra Mishra was recorded under Section 131 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 on 11.04.2014 where he admitted about formation of the companies with the sole purpose of routing unaccounted funds/money in the guise of share capital/premium. These companies were used to provide accommodation entries, which was re-confirmed by other witness Shri Santosh Kumar Shah. It was admitted that the entities were incorporated with the sole purpose of routing the funds. The Income Tax Department accordingly conducted a search on the premises of the benamidar on 22.03.2018. The statement of Shri Kashi Prasad Chotia, Director of the respondent company M/s Aachman Vanijya Pvt. Ltd. was recorded. Shri Chotia admitted that he was a dummy Director and that benamidar company did not conduct any business so as to provide source for the purchase of the property. Based on the material collected during the course of investigation, a case of benami transaction was found and accordingly an order for provisional attachment of the property was issued. However, upon a reference of the case to the Adjudicating Authority, he denied to confirm the provisional attachment of the property and even rejected the reference.
Summary and findings of the case vis-à-vis rival submissions:
3. The learned Adjudicating Authority first considered the issue in reference to the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of Hon’ble Supreme Court in Union of India v. Ganpati Dealcom (P.) Ltd. [2022] 141 taxmann.com 389/289 Taxman 177/447 ITR 108 (SC)/(2022) 447 ITR 108 (SC). It was held that the Amending Act of 2016 to amend the Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988 would apply prospectively. The transactions herein were found to be prior to the amendment of certain provisions vide the Amending Act of 2016, thus, the matter is to be governed by the judgment in the case of Ganpati Dealcom (supra). It is, however, a fact that the judgment in the case of Ganpati Dealcom (supra) has been recalled by the Apex Court vide its order dated 18.10.2024 in Union of India v. Ganpati Dealcom (P.) Ltd. [2024] 167 taxmann.com 525/301 Taxman 313/[2025] 474 ITR 354 (SC) and, therefore, the parties did not press the issue, in reference to the judgment in the case of Ganpati Dealcom (supra). Rather, both the parties prayed for consideration of the case on merits and the appeal has been taken for consideration of the case on merit.
4. It was found by the Adjudicating Authority that no show cause notice under Section 24(1) of the Act of 1988 was issued for two movable assets, yet provisional attachment under Section 24(4)(a)(i) of the Act of 1988 was caused. The action of the appellant Department was not in accordance with the provisions of law in view of the fact that order under Section 24(4)(a)(i) of the Act of 1988 can be passed only for the property for which Provisional Attachment Order was caused under Section 24(3) of the Act of 1988. In the instant case, no order was passed under Section 24(3) of the Act of 1988 in respect of two movable properties. The order for provisional attachment of the movable property was yet passed and, therefore, the Adjudicating Authority interfered in the action of the appellant Department for two movable properties. We do not find any illegality in the order because an order under Section 24(4)(a)(i) of the Act of 1988 can be passed for the properties for which the provisional attachment was caused under Section 24(3) of the Act of 1988 and if any other property has to be provisionally attached, the appellant Department could have invoked Section 24(4)(b)(i) of the Act of 1988 and not Section 24(4)(a)(i) of the Act of 1988.
5. The Adjudicating Authority thereafter taken up the issue about failure of the Initiating Officer to refer to the provision under which the transaction is to be held benami. It is either referring to Section 2(9)(A) or any other provision, which may be Sections 2(9)(B), 2(9)(C) or 2(9)(D) of the Act of 1988. In the instant case, reference of the provision was not given in the show cause notice and otherwise the Adjudicating Authority had taken Section 2(9)(A) and 2(9)(D) of the Act of 1988 to be mutually contradictory in nature. In absence of reference of the provision to cause Provisional Attachment Order, the Adjudicating Authority accepted the argument of the counsel for the respondents. The finding recorded by the Adjudicating Authority is not worth acceptance because if a reference of the relevant provision is not given or incorrect provision is referred, it would not be an illegal order if the facts referred therein discloses a case of benami transaction under either of the provisions. Non-reference or a wrong reference of the provisions cannot be said to be a fatal if case is made out to show benami transaction under either of the provisions applicable for it.
6. The next question taken up by the Adjudicating Authority was that the Initiating Officer had placed blind reliance on the various statements recorded by the Income Tax Department. The Initiating Officer failed to make inquiry to collect the independent evidence and accordingly finding was recorded favourable to the respondents and against the appellant Department. The serious contest was made on the aforesaid issue. We find substance in the argument of the appellant Department in view of the fact that the evidence collected in the Income Tax proceedings can be relied and otherwise it is a fact that the appellant Department has also collected the evidence. Thus, in view of the above, the argument that the appellant failed to collect the evidence independently could not have been accepted to cause interference in the Provisional Attachment Order.
7. The Adjudicating Authority thereupon examined the facts of the case to determine whether a case of benami transaction is made out on the basis of the material produced by the parties, even if the legal grounds challenging the Provisional Attachment Order are ignored. The Adjudicating Authority found that the substantial capital was introduced in the year 2006-07, when the shares were allotted to the companies at a high premium. However, the property was not purchased soon thereafter or within a reasonable period; rather, it was purchased after a long gap of around 8-9 years. Thus, the conclusion that the consideration for the property was paid by the beneficial owner out of the premium charged on allotment of shares could not have been accepted, particularly in view of the long-time gap between the two transactions. The parties also failed to establish an essential nexus between the alleged share capital and share premium received prior to the year 2006-07 and the consideration paid for the property in the year 2015. It could have been concluded that, after a period of 8-9 years, the premium amount was utilised for the purchase of the property. We find substance in the findings recorded by the Adjudicating Authority, particularly in view of the fact that no evidence could be collected by the appellant Department to show that the share premium was used for the purchase of the property. This is more so when the burden lies on the person making allegations of a benami transaction. It is also when allotment of shares on premium was not to one company but many companies, thus, it could not have been concluded that premium collected from one company was used for the purchase of the property.
8. The Initiating Officer further considered another aspect of the matter to find out as to whether a case is made out under Section 2(9)(A) of the Act of 1988. To make out a case of benami transaction, consideration for purchase of the property in the name of other person is to be paid by the beneficial owner for his future benefit. In the instant case, the appellant Department failed to show that transaction for purchase of the property under provisional attachment was for the future benefit of the beneficial owner. The property under attachment remains with the alleged benamidar. The Adjudicating Authority has recorded the finding against the appellant-Department and we find no perversity in it. The appellant failed to make out a case of benami transaction.
9. The learned Adjudicating Authority further found that the allotment of shares on premium was not only to the respondent- Company but also to many other companies, thus, an inference could not have been drawn for a benami transaction on allotment of the shares on premium by the respondent-company when it was allotted to many other companies also. It is also a fact that even prior to the year 2006-07, the shares were allotted in the year 2003-04 at the premium of Rs.490/-. It was even in the year 2004-05. In the year 2005-06, it was at the premium of Rs.590/-. The amount collected in earlier years before 2006-07 has been ignored otherwise it was available for purchase of the property in question. The statement disclosing the premium charged in different years has been reflected in the impugned order. The Adjudicating Authority found that the appellant Department ignored the premium amount received by the respondent company. The appellant could not otherwise prove that the premium amount received during the year 2006-07 was utilized for the purchase of the property. We do not find any error in the finding.
10. Further, the Initiating Officer attributed the source for the purchase of the properties in 2015 to the share premium infused through shares issued by the benamidar company in the year 2006–07. However, the Respondents failed to provide any substantive material to this attribution. The contention of the IO was rejected by the learned Adjudicating Authority on the ground that the Respondent Company had specifically and cogently explained that the funds deployed for the purchase were generated through the liquidation of its investments and Mutual Funds amounting to Rs.32.40 crores, out of which approximately Rs.30 crores were utilized for the acquisition of immovable property. The respondents relied upon their financial records, audited accounts, and documents demonstrating the source of funds out of investments and Mutual Fund liquidations. After going through the record, we are of the view that the Adjudicating Authority has recorded a proper finding on the issue, thus remains no reason to interfere with the finding of the Adjudicating Authority.
11. In the light of the aforesaid, the findings recorded by the Adjudicating Authority on merits are accepted without causing interference therein though we have not agreed to the findings recorded on certain aspects, but it does not affect the final outcome of the impugned order and accordingly appeal fails and is dismissed.