Recovery Against Directors of Companies in Liquidation (Section 88) 1. The Core Dispute: Vicarious Liability vs. Liquidation Control The Revenue initiated recovery proceedings against the individual directors of a company undergoing liquidation by attaching their personal bank accounts. The demand pertained to arrears of interest and penalty that remained unpaid after the principal tax amount… Read More »
High Court Quashes “Negative Blocking” of Electronic Credit Ledger 1. The Core Dispute: “Negative Blocking” vs. Available Credit The tax authorities blocked the petitioner’s Electronic Credit Ledger (ECL) under Rule 86A. Crucially, the authorities inserted a negative balance in the ledger. This meant that even though the petitioner had a “NIL” balance at the time… Read More »
GST Rate Change and the Time of Supply (Section 14) 1. The Conflict: 12% vs. 18% GST The petitioner completed a project on June 8, 2022, during which the applicable GST rate was 12%. However, a rate increase to 18% took effect on July 18, 2022. The third respondent (contractor/supplier) raised the invoice only after… Read More »
Invalidation of Composite Show Cause Notices for Multiple Tax Periods 1. The Core Dispute: Consolidation of Tax Periods The revenue authorities issued a single, consolidated Show Cause Notice (SCN) covering multiple financial years (typically ranging from FY 2019-20 to 2021-22 or beyond). The petitioner challenged this “bunching” of years, arguing that it violated the fundamental… Read More »
IMPORTANT GST CASE LAWS 07.02.2026 Relevant Act Section Case Law Title Brief Summary Citation CGST Act, 2017 Section 67 Reevan Creation v. State of Gujarat [Seizure Limitation] Under Section 67(7), seized goods/cash must be returned if no notice is issued within six months. Failure to issue a notice or a Section 130 confiscation notice within… Read More »
GST Exemption for Environmental Preservation by Charitable Trusts 1. The Core Dispute: Are Non-Forest Tree Plantations “Charitable”? The applicant, a charitable institution registered under Section 12AB of the Income-tax Act, sought clarity on its primary activity: the large-scale plantation and long-term maintenance of trees. These activities were carried out in non-forest areas, including barren lands,… Read More »
Remand for GSTR-1 & GSTR-3B Mismatch Analysis (FY 2020-21) 1. The Core Dispute: Clerical Error vs. Tax Liability The dispute arose from a significant discrepancy identified between the assessee’s GSTR-1 (Statement of Outward Supplies) and GSTR-3B (Monthly Summary Return). The Revenue noted that the liability reported in GSTR-3B was less than that in GSTR-1, leading… Read More »
No Anti-Profiteering Contravened in Post-GST Construction Projects 1. The Core Dispute: Alleged Profiteering on Post-GST Bookings An applicant (homebuyer) who booked a flat in 2019 in the residential project ‘Urban-67A’, Gurugram, alleged that the developer failed to pass on the benefit of Input Tax Credit (ITC). The buyer contended that under Section 171, the developer… Read More »
Permission for Manual GSTR-3B Filing to Correct Omitted ITC (FY 2020-21) 1. The Core Dispute: Omitted ITC & Lack of Rectification Mechanism The petitioner inadvertantly omitted claiming Input Tax Credit (ITC) for January and February 2021 in their original GSTR-3B for the quarter ending March 2021. Discovery of Error: The mistake was noticed during the… Read More »
Statutory Release of Seized Goods and Bank Accounts (FY 2021-22) 1. The Core Dispute: Failure to Meet Statutory Timelines In March 2022, tax authorities conducted a search and seizure operation, resulting in the seizure of gold, silver, and cash, followed by the provisional attachment of the petitioner’s bank accounts. The petitioner challenged the continued retention… Read More »