Daily Archives: December 1, 2025

Transfer Pricing: Netflix India characterized as Limited Risk Distributor; TNMM upheld over TPO’s Royalty Model

By | December 1, 2025

I. Transfer Pricing: Netflix India characterized as Limited Risk Distributor; TNMM upheld over TPO’s Royalty Model Issue Characterization: Whether the assessee (Netflix India) should be characterized as a Limited Risk Distributor (LRD) of access to streaming services or as an entrepreneurial service provider owning intangible assets. Methodology: Whether the Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM) using… Read More »

Addition under Section 69 for cash deposits up to ₹2.5 Lakhs during demonetization deleted per CBDT Instruction 3/2017

By | December 1, 2025

Addition under Section 69 for cash deposits up to ₹2.5 Lakhs during demonetization deleted per CBDT Instruction 3/2017 Issue Section 69 Addition: Whether the Assessing Officer (AO) was justified in making an addition of ₹2 Lakhs under Section 69 for cash deposits made during the demonetization period, despite CBDT Instruction No. 3/2017 which directed no… Read More »

Detailed documentation of share transactions defeats “Penny Stock” addition under Section 68

By | December 1, 2025

Detailed documentation of share transactions defeats “Penny Stock” addition under Section 68 Issue Whether the Assessing Officer (AO) is justified in treating the sale proceeds of shares as “unexplained cash credit” under Section 68 solely on the suspicion of them being “penny stocks,” when the assessee has provided complete documentary evidence substantiating the genuineness of… Read More »

Section 10AA deduction allowed on voluntary TP adjustment under APA; Ad-hoc Section 14A disallowance deleted

By | December 1, 2025

Section 10AA deduction allowed on voluntary TP adjustment under APA; Ad-hoc Section 14A disallowance deleted Case I: Transfer Pricing & Section 10AA   Issue Whether a taxpayer is entitled to claim a deduction under Section 10AA (for SEZ units) on the additional income voluntarily offered as a Transfer Pricing (TP) adjustment pursuant to an Advance… Read More »

TPO must adhere to own turnover filters; PF delay due to banking glitch distinguishable from Checkmate ruling

By | December 1, 2025

TPO must adhere to own turnover filters; PF delay due to banking glitch distinguishable from Checkmate ruling Case I: Transfer Pricing – Consistency in Filters   Issue Whether the Transfer Pricing Officer (TPO) is justified in including a comparable company that fails the specific turnover filter applied by the TPO himself during the benchmarking process… Read More »

IMPORTANT GST CASE LAWS 01.12.25

By | December 1, 2025

IMPORTANT GST CASE LAWS 01.12.25 Section Case Law Title Brief Summary Citation Relevant Act 54 Shah Paperplast Industries Ltd. v. Union of India Refund of Input Tax Credit (ITC) to a 100% EOU was restored because the unit made actual zero-rated exports, making CBIC Circular No. 172/04/2022-GST inapplicable. Withdrawal of the refund was quashed. Click… Read More »

Category: GST

Ex parte order set aside on costs as petitioner unaware until CA visited GST office

By | December 1, 2025

Ex parte order set aside on costs as petitioner unaware until CA visited GST office Issue Whether a writ petition is maintainable against an adjudication order passed ex parte when the petitioner claims lack of knowledge of the proceedings until their Chartered Accountant discovered the order during a visit to the GST office. Facts Challenge:… Read More »

Category: GST

Masterminds of fake firms are taxable persons liable for penalties under GST Act Section 122

By | December 1, 2025

Masterminds of fake firms are taxable persons liable for penalties under GST Act Section 122 Issue Whether a director or partner, who is the actual beneficiary and mastermind behind non-existent or fake firms, qualifies as a “taxable person” liable for penalties under Section 122(1) of the CGST Act, 2017. Facts Show Cause Notice: A Show… Read More »

Category: GST

Ex parte order quashed as SCN uploaded to Additional Notices tab violated natural justice

By | December 1, 2025

Ex parte order quashed as SCN uploaded to Additional Notices tab violated natural justice Issue Natural Justice: Whether an adjudication order passed ex parte is valid when the Show Cause Notice (SCN) was uploaded solely under the “Additional Notices” tab, preventing the petitioner from filing a reply. Limitation Validity: Whether the time limit extension for… Read More »

Category: GST